A Comparison of Field and Laboratory Polygraphs in the Detection of Deception
- 1 November 1991
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Psychophysiology
- Vol. 28 (6), 632-638
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-8986.1991.tb01006.x
Abstract
This study compared the effectiveness of field and laboratory polygraphs in discriminating guilty and innocent subjects tested using the Control Question Technique (CQT). Subjects were 48 prisoners examined regarding a mock theft in a peer threat context; physiological responses were recorded simultaneously on a Lafayette field polygraph and a Sensor Medics laboratory polygraph. Overall hit rates were essentially the same whether classifications were based on quantitative measures from the laboratory polygraph or on numerical scores from the field polygraph (i.e., 73% and 79%, respectively), and in both cases the best discriminating measures were electrodermal activity and indices of respiration suppression. Further analyses revealed that errors of classification were mostly due to the failure of the available measures to differentiate between relevant and control questions for innocent subjects. These results indicate that the CQT is susceptible to false positive errors when subjects are tested under field‐like circumstances, a problem that is not likely to be eliminated by refinements in instrumentation and scoring.This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Validity of the control question polygraph test: The problem of sampling bias.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1991
- Validity of the control question polygraph test: The problem of sampling bias.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1991
- Psychopathy, threat, and polygraph test accuracy.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1989
- Psychopathy, threat, and polygraph test accuracy.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1989
- Human versus computerized evaluations of polygraph data in a laboratory setting.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1988
- A research scale for the assessment of psychopathy in criminal populationsPersonality and Individual Differences, 1980
- Psychopathy and Detection of Deception In a Prison PopulationPsychophysiology, 1978
- Correcting psychophysiological measures for individual differences in range.Psychological Bulletin, 1966
- An Extension of Box's Results on the Use of the $F$ Distribution in Multivariate AnalysisThe Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 1958