Policy Success, Policy Failure and Grey Areas In-Between
Top Cited Papers
- 4 November 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Public Policy
- Vol. 30 (3), 345-362
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0143814x10000152
Abstract
Policy protagonists are keen to claim that policy is successful while opponents are more likely to frame policies as failures. The reality is that policy outcomes are often somewhere in between these extremes. An added difficulty is that policy has multiple dimensions, often succeeding in some respects but not in others, according to facts and their interpretation. This paper sets out a framework designed to capture the bundles of outcomes that indicate how successful or unsuccessful a policy has been. It reviews existing literature on policy evaluation and improvement, public value, good practice, political strategy and policy failure and success in order to identify what can be built on and gaps that need to be filled. It conceives policy as having three realms: processes, programs and politics. Policies may succeed and/or fail in each of these and along a spectrum of success, resilient success, conflicted success, precarious success and failure. It concludes by examining contradictions between different forms of success, including what is known colloquially as good politics but bad policy.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- A COMMENT ON MARSH AND McCONNELL: TOWARDS A FRAMEWORK FOR ESTABLISHING POLICY SUCCESSPublic Administration, 2010
- Turnaround of the Indian Railways: a public ownership sagaInternational Journal of Public Policy, 2010
- BRINGING THE POLITICS BACK IN: PUBLIC VALUE IN WESTMINSTER PARLIAMENTARY GOVERNMENTPublic Administration, 2009
- The Limits to Public Value, or Rescuing Responsible Government from the Platonic GuardiansAustralian Journal of Public Administration, 2007
- Learning to Walk Slow: America's Partial Policy Success in the Arena of Intellectual DisabilityJournal of Policy History, 2007
- Rituals of Reform, Policy Transfer, and the National University Corporation Reforms of JapanGovernance, 2006
- Explaining Australian Economic Success: Good Policy or Good Luck?Governance, 2006
- Mapping Public Participation in Policy ChoicesAustralian Journal of Public Administration, 2002
- Accountability, New Public Management, and the Problems of the Child Support AgencyJournal of Law and Society, 1999
- The Science of "Muddling Through"Public Administration Review, 1959