Non-Consensual Treatment is (Nearly Always) Morally Impermissible
- 1 January 2010
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics
- Vol. 38 (4), 789-798
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-720x.2010.00532.x
Abstract
The goal of my comments regarding the case study of Eve Hyde — presented in the introduction of this symposium — is not first and foremost to resolve the conflict between individual autonomy and medical paternalism regarding non-consensual psychiatric treatment. Instead, the goal is to step back far enough from what is generally accepted as the morally appropriate basis for non-consensual psychiatric treatment, including involuntary hospitalization and medication, and to ask very basic questions about when patients may permissibly be treated without their consent. My goal, in short, is Socratic — to explore aspects of what we take for granted in order better to determine whether we ought to take them for granted. Commentators routinely urge that it is morally permissible forcibly to treat psychiatric patients, such as Eve Hyde, in order to preserve the patient’s best interests and restore the patient’s autonomy. Such arguments typically specify duties of beneficence toward others, while appreciating personal autonomy as a positive value to be weighed against other factors.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Psychiatric Advance Directives and the Right to Refuse Treatment in CanadaThe Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 2007
- Evaluation of Competency: Ethical Considerations for NeuropsychologistsApplied Neuropsychology, 2006
- Psychiatric ethics; a critical introduction for mental health nursesJournal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 2004
- Informed Consent in Texas: Theory and PracticeJournal of Medicine and Philosophy, 2004
- Does fear of coercion keep people away from mental health treatment? Evidence from a survey of persons with schizophrenia and mental health professionalsBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2003
- Self-reported symptoms and treatment outcome among non-offending involuntary inpatientsJournal of Forensic Psychiatry, 2002
- A plea for respect: involuntarily hospitalized psychiatric patients’ narratives about being subjected to coercionJournal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 2001
- Psychiatrists and Compulsion: A Map of EthicsAustralian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 1998
- Serious criminal offending and mental disorderThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 1998
- Making mental health care decisions: Informed consent and involuntary civil commitmentBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 1983