Mapping the Mind Gap: A Comparison of US and European Security Strategies
- 1 March 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Security Dialogue
- Vol. 36 (1), 71-92
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0967010605051925
Abstract
This article analyses the state of the transatlantic security relationship by comparing two recent key documents: the Bush administration’s National Security Strategy (NSS) and the EU’s European Security Strategy (ESS). Deploying Robert Kagan’s caricature of differing strategic cultures between Europeans and Americans as an analytical foil, it assesses both documents with regard to how they define (i) realms of responsibility, (ii) threat assessments and (iii) tasks and instruments necessary to address these threats. Despite semantic overlaps and a sense of common commitment, the findings confirm divergent strategic thinking between European and US policymakers in all three areas. Although some of the differences run along well-known fault lines, the comparison reveals a mind gap that is significantly different from the one outlined by Kagan in one crucial aspect: it shows a US agenda guided by utopian thinking, and a European strategy that appears more realistic.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bush's Foreign PolicyForeign Policy, 2004
- Not such a soft power: the external deployment of European forcesSurvival, 2004
- Liberal empireJournal of International Relations and Development, 2004
- Utopianism and the Bush foreign policyCambridge Review of International Affairs, 2004
- American Public Diplomacy as Pseudo-Education: A Problematic National Security and Counter-Terrorism InstrumentInternational Politics, 2004
- The Question of Power: Europe versus AmericaConstellations, 2003
- Command of the Commons: The Military Foundation of U.S. HegemonyInternational Security, 2003
- Commentary: Martians and Venutians in the new world orderInternational Affairs, 2003
- The imperial logic of Bush's liberal agendaSurvival, 2003
- Europe, the Necessary PartnerForeign Affairs, 2001