Effect of Think-Aloud Instruction on Elementary Students' Comprehension Monitoring Abilities
Open Access
- 1 June 1992
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Reading Behavior
- Vol. 24 (2), 143-172
- https://doi.org/10.1080/10862969209547770
Abstract
This study investigated the effectiveness of explicit instruction in think aloud as a means to promote elementary students' comprehension monitoring abilities. Sixty-six fourth-grade students were randomly assigned to one of three experimental groups: (a) a Think-Aloud (TA) group, in which students were taught various comprehension monitoring strategies for reading stories (e.g., self-questioning, prediction, retelling, rereading) through the medium of thinking aloud; (b) a Directed Reading-Thinking Activity (DRTA) group, in which students were taught a predict-verify strategy for reading and responding to stories; or (c) a Directed Reading Activity (DRA) group, an instructed control, in which students engaged in a noninteractive, guided reading of stories. The primary quantitative analyses involved two planned orthogonal contrasts—effect of instruction (TA + DRTA vs. 2 x DRA) and intensity of instruction (TA vs. DRTA)—for three whole-sample dependent measures: (a) an error detection test, (b) a comprehension monitoring questionnaire, and (c) a modified cloze test. Results of effect of instruction contrasts revealed that TA and DRTA students were more skillful at comprehension monitoring than DRA students (TA + DRTA>DRA for all three measures). Results of intensity of instruction contrasts indicated that although TA-trained students had greater awareness of comprehension monitoring abilities (TA>DRTA for the questionnaire), DRTA students' performance equaled (TA = DRTA for the cloze test) or exceeded (TAKeywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effects of Inference Training on Comprehension and Comprehension MonitoringReading Research Quarterly, 1987
- Mental Imagery and the Comprehension-Monitoring Performance of Fourth- and Fifth-Grade Poor ReadersReading Research Quarterly, 1986
- Use of Thinking Aloud in Identification and Teaching of Reading Comprehension StrategiesCognition and Instruction, 1985
- On the Use of Verbal Reports in Reading ResearchJournal of Reading Behavior, 1984
- Comparison of Comprehension Monitoring of Skilled and Less Skilled ReadersReading Research Quarterly, 1984
- Second Graders’ Strategic Preferences While Reading Basal StoriesThe Journal of Educational Research, 1984
- Metamemory: A Critical ExaminationChild Development, 1982
- Verbal reports as data.Psychological Review, 1980
- Comprehension Monitoring: Identifying and Coping with Text ConfusionsJournal of Reading Behavior, 1979
- The Development of Memory: Knowing, Knowing About Knowing, and Knowing How to KnowAdvances in Child Development and Behavior, 1975