Patterns of ‘leakage’ in the utilisation of clinical guidelines: a systematic review
Open Access
- 29 June 2011
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- Vol. 87 (1032), 670-679
- https://doi.org/10.1136/pgmj.2010.116012
Abstract
Background Research evidence is insufficient to change physicians' behaviour. In 1996, Pathman developed a four step model: that physicians need to be aware of, agree with, adopt, and adhere to guidelines. Objective To review evidence in different settings on the patterns of ‘leakage’ in the utilisation of clinical guidelines using Pathman's awareness-to-adherence model. Methods A systematic review was conducted in June 2010. Primary studies were included if they reported on rates of awareness and agreement and adoption and/or adherence. Results 11 primary studies were identified, reporting on 29 recommendations. Descriptive analyses of patterns and causes of leakage were tabulated and graphed. Leakage was progressive across all four steps. Median adherence from all recommendations was 34%, suggesting that potential benefits for patients from health research may be lost. There was considerable variation across different types of guidelines. Recommendations for drug interventions, vaccination and health promotion activities showed high rates of awareness. Leakage was most pronounced between adoption and adherence for drug recommendations and between awareness and agreement for medical management recommendations. Barriers were reported differentially for all steps of the model. Conclusion Leakage from research publication to guideline utilisation occurs in a wide variety of clinical settings and at all steps of the awareness-to-adherence pathway. This review confirms that clinical guidelines are insufficient to implement research and suggests there may be different factors influencing clinicians at each step of this pathway. Recommendations to improve guideline adherence need to be tailored to each step.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cardiologists' awareness and perceptions of guidelines for chronic heart failure. The ADDress your Heart surveyEuropean Journal of Heart Failure, 2008
- Hypertension guideline recommendations in general practice: awareness, agreement, adoption, and adherenceBritish Journal of General Practice, 2007
- A survey of awareness, opinion and reported use of clinical practice guidelines (CPG) of the Royal College of Anesthesiologists of Thailand.2007
- Specialty Differences in Prescribing Inhaled Corticosteroids for ChildrenClinical Pediatrics, 2007
- Physicians' attitudes to the pharmacological treatment of patients with stable angina pectorisQJM: An International Journal of Medicine, 2004
- Well-Child Visits in the Video Age: Pediatricians and the American Academy of Pediatrics’ Guidelines for Children's Media UsePEDIATRICS, 2004
- How well do patients report noncompliance with antihypertensive medications?: a comparison of self-report versus filled prescriptionsPharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2003
- The Impact of Practice Guidelines in the Management of Barrett EsophagusArchives of Internal Medicine, 2001
- Why Don't Physicians Follow Clinical Practice Guidelines?JAMA, 1999
- The Awareness-to-Adherence Model of the Steps to Clinical Guideline ComplianceMedical Care, 1996