Congruence of molecules and morphology using a narrow allometric approach
- 17 July 2007
- journal article
- Published by Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
- Vol. 104 (29), 11910-11914
- https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0702174104
Abstract
There are many cases of incongruence between phylogenetic hypotheses produced from morphological data and those produced from molecular data. In such instances, many researchers prefer to accept the results of molecular phylogenies. For example, in a recent analysis of primate phylogenies based on craniodental characters, Collard and Wood [Collard M, Wood BA (2000) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:5003-5006] argued that, because craniodental data do not yield relationships concordant with molecular studies, the results of studies that employ such characters must be considered suspect. As most of our knowledge of mammalian evolution and phylogenetic history comes from craniodental fossils, these results have dramatic implications. However, the aforementioned analysis did not take into account the potentially confounding effects of allometry on quantitative craniodental characters. In this article, we employ a previously undescribed narrow allometric coding method that accounts for such confounding influences in phylogenetic analyses of craniodental morphology. By using essentially the same raw data set as Collard and Wood [Collard M, Wood BA (2000) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:5003-5006], 65 quantitative craniodental characters were adjusted in a parsimony analysis for the primate tribe Papionini, a group of monkeys argued to display extensive homoplasy. The resulting phylogenetic tree was congruent with the phylogenetic tree based on molecular data for these species, thereby meeting the "criterion of congruence." These results suggest that morphological data, when treated properly, can be considered as reliable as molecular data in phylogenetic reconstruction. Rather than accepting phylogenetic hypotheses from one data source over another, cases of incongruence should be examined with greater scrutiny.This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- Resolution of the Early Placental Mammal Radiation Using Bayesian PhylogeneticsScience, 2001
- Skeletons of terrestrial cetaceans and the relationship of whales to artiodactylsNature, 2001
- The Evolution of the Scrotum and Testicular Descent in Mammals: a Phylogenetic ViewJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1999
- Evidence from milk casein genes that cetaceans are close relatives of hippopotamid artiodactylsMolecular Biology and Evolution, 1996
- A molecular perspective on the phylogeny of placental mammals based on mitochondrial 12S rDNA sequences, with special reference to the problem of the PaenungulataJournal of Mammalian Evolution, 1993
- The role of phenacodontids in the origin of the modern orders of ungulate mammalsJournal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 1992
- AMNIOTE PHYLOGENY AND THE IMPORTANCE OF FOSSILSCladistics, 1988
- Canonical and principal components of shapeBiometrika, 1985
- Confidence Limits on Phylogenies: An Approach Using the BootstrapEvolution, 1985
- Size Allometry: Size and Shape Variables with Characterizations of the Lognormal and Generalized Gamma DistributionsJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1970