Management by Grid® Principles or Situationalism: Which?
- 1 December 1981
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Group & Organization Studies
- Vol. 6 (4), 439-455
- https://doi.org/10.1177/105960118100600404
Abstract
Leadership theory has been conceived in two different and incompatible ways. Hersey and Blanchard's analysis entails arithmetic combinations of the task and people variables, whereas Blake and Mouton's approach involves znteraction of the two. Examined in this way, Hersey and Blanchard's model eliminates a "9,9" or "one-best-way" orientation. When 9,9 options were added to this model, managers and mental health experts uniformly chose the 9,9 alternative and rejected situationally prescribed answers. This generalization held for all maturity levels. This fundamental difference in how leadership is conceived is then used to reinterpret major leadership research since World War II. Instruments based on adding magnitudes of variables, such as Fleishman, Reddin, and Hersey and Blanchard, among others, have shown no validity from an empirical standpoint, whereas instruments based on an interaction of variables—such as those by Likert, Argyris, and Blake and Mouton—have consistently demonstrated predictive validity. This paper provides a resolution for the controversy between situationalism and the one-best-style approach and indicates the validity of the latter and the lack of predictive value of the former.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- MANAGERS AND THE HI-HI LEADER MYTH.The Academy of Management Journal, 1978
- The Great Hi-Hi Leader Behavior Myth: A Lesson from Occam's Razor.The Academy of Management Journal, 1976
- To Achieve or Not: The Manager's ChoiceCalifornia Management Review, 1976
- Administrative behavior and student dissatisfaction: A possible relationshipPeabody Journal of Education, 1973
- “Consideration,”“Initiating Structure,” and Organizational Criteria‐ a ReviewPersonnel Psychology, 1966
- A Contingency Model of Leadership EffectivenessAdvances in Experimental Social Psychology, 1964
- Conformity and character.American Psychologist, 1955
- The measurement of leadership attitudes in industry.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1953
- HospitalismThe Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, 1946
- Frustration and regression: An experiment with young children.Published by American Psychological Association (APA) ,1941