Unrelated cord blood and mismatched unrelated volunteer donor transplants, two alternatives in patients who lack an HLA-identical donor

Abstract

The aim was to evaluate two transplant strategies for patients who lack HLA-identical donors, namely HLA-A, HLA-B or -DRβ1 mismatched unrelated donor (MM URD) transplants (n=14) and umbilical cord blood transplants (UCB, n=27). Diagnosis, disease stage and age were similar in the two groups. Cell dose was lower in the UCB group (P0.5 × 10⁹/l was 30 days in the UCB group and 17 days in the MM URD group (P=0.002). Engraftment of plt was delayed in the UCB group (P=0.03). The UCB patients required fewer erythrocyte transfusions (P=0.001). At 100 days, complete donor chimerism for CD3 was 63 and 44% in the UCB and MM URD groups, respectively. Acute GVHD of grades II–IV were 30% in the UCB group and 21% in the MM URD group. The corresponding figures for chronic GVHD were 9 and 20%, respectively. TRM was 30% in the UCB patients and 50% in the MM URD patients. Three-year survival was 66% in the UCB group and 14% in the MM URD group (P=0.006). Although the material is small and heterogeneous, engraftment was delayed, leukocyte chimerism was not significantly different and survival was superior using UCB rather than MM URD transplants.