Reference Pricing For Drugs: Is It Compatible With U.S. Health Care?

Abstract

To control spending on prescription drugs, health insurance systems abroad have experimented in recent years with a novel form of patient cost sharing called “reference pricing.” Under this approach, the insurer covers only the prices of low-cost, benchmark drugs in therapeutic clusters that are deemed to be close substitutes for one another in treating specific illnesses. Patients who desire a higher-price substitute in a cluster must then pay the full difference between the retail price of that drug and the reference price covered by the insurer. This paper explores the difficult trade-offs that policymakers must make in designing such a system, drawing where relevant from experience abroad.