Box-Counting Dimension Revisited: Presenting an Efficient Method of Minimizing Quantization Error and an Assessment of the Self-Similarity of Structural Root Systems
Open Access
- 18 February 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Plant Science
- Vol. 7, 149
- https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2016.00149
Abstract
Fractal dimension (FD), estimated by box-counting, is a metric used to characterise plant anatomical complexity or space-filling characteristic for a variety of purposes. The vast majority of published studies fail to evaluate the assumption of statistical self-similarity, which underpins the validity of the procedure. The box-counting procedure is also subject to error arising from arbitrary grid placement, known as quantisation error (QE), which is strictly positive and varies as a function of scale, making it problematic for the procedure's slope estimation step. Previous studies either ignore QE or employ inefficient brute-force grid translations to reduce it. The goals of this study were to characterise the effect of QE due to translation and rotation on FD estimates, to provide an efficient method of reducing QE, and to evaluate the assumption of statistical self-similarity of coarse root datasets typical of those used in recent trait studies. Coarse root systems of 36 shrubs were digitised in 3D and subjected to box-counts. A pattern search algorithm was used to minimise QE by optimising grid placement and its efficiency was compared to the brute force method. The degree of statistical self-similarity was evaluated using linear regression residuals and local slope estimates. QE due to both grid position and orientation was a significant source of error in FD estimates, but pattern search provided an efficient means of minimising it. Pattern search had higher initial computational cost but converged on lower error values more efficiently than the commonly employed brute force method. Our representations of coarse root system digitisations did not exhibit details over a sufficient range of scales to be considered statistically self-similar and informatively approximated as fractals, suggesting a lack of sufficient ramification of the coarse root systems for reiteration to be thought of as a dominant force in their development. FD estimates did not characterise the scaling of our digitisations well: the scaling exponent was a function of scale. Our findings serve as a caution against applying FD under the assumption of statistical self-similarity without rigorously evaluating it first.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Department of Agriculture (2009-35900-06016)
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Jatropha curcasL. Root Structure and Growth in Diverse SoilsThe Scientific World Journal, 2013
- Descendant root volume varies as a function of root type: estimation of root biomass lost during uprooting in Pinus pinasterFrontiers in Plant Science, 2013
- Plant architecture, its diversity and manipulation in agronomic conditions, in relation with pest and pathogen attacksEuropean Journal of Plant Pathology, 2012
- Garlic Mustard (Alliaria petiolata) Removal Method Affects Native EstablishmentInvasive Plant Science and Management, 2009
- Fractal analysis on root systems of rice plants in response to drought stressEnvironmental and Experimental Botany, 2009
- Plant Light Interception Can Be Explained via Computed Tomography Scanning: Demonstration with Pyramidal Cedar (Thuja occidentalis, Fastigiata)Annals of Botany, 2007
- Plant Architecture: A Dynamic, Multilevel and Comprehensive Approach to Plant Form, Structure and OntogenyAnnals of Botany, 2007
- Advances in the acquisition and analysis of CT scan data to isolate a crop root system from the soil medium and quantify root system complexity in 3-D spaceGeoderma, 2006
- Fractal and Multifractal Analysis of Cassava Root System Grown by the Root-Box MethodPlant Production Science, 2002
- Local Fractal Dimensions and Multifractal Analysis of the Root System of LegumesPlant Production Science, 2000