Identifying and Remediating Student Misconceptions in Introductory Biology via Writing-to-Learn Assignments and Peer Review
Open Access
- 1 June 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Society for Cell Biology (ASCB) in CBE—Life Sciences Education
- Vol. 17 (2), ar28
- https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.17-10-0212
Abstract
Student misconceptions are an obstacle in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics courses and unless remediated may continue causing difficulties in learning as students advance in their studies. Writing-to-learn assignments (WTL) are characterized by their ability to promote in-depth conceptual learning by allowing students to explore their understanding of a topic. This study sought to determine whether and what types of misconceptions are elicited by WTL assignments and how the process of peer review and revision leads to remediation or propagation of misconceptions. We examined four WTL assignments in an introductory biology course in which students first wrote about content by applying it to a realistic scenario, then participated in a peer-review process before revising their work. Misconceptions were identified in all four assignments, with the greatest number pertaining to protein structure and function. Additionally, in certain contexts, students used scientific terminology incorrectly. Analysis of the drafts and peer-review comments generated six profiles by which misconceptions were addressed through the peer-review process. The prevalent mode of remediation arose through directed peer-review comments followed by correction during revision. It was also observed that additional misconceptions were elicited as students revised their writing in response to general peer-review suggestions.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Short Lesson Plan Associated with Increased Acceptance of Evolutionary Theory and Potential Change in Three Alternate Conceptions of Macroevolution in Undergraduate StudentsCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2012
- Writing-to-Learn in Undergraduate Science Education: A Community-Based, Conceptually Driven ApproachCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2012
- Exploring Undergraduates' Understanding of Photosynthesis Using Diagnostic Question ClustersCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2012
- A Diagnostic Assessment for Introductory Molecular and Cell BiologyCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2010
- Mathematics, Thermodynamics, and Modeling to Address Ten Common Misconceptions about Protein Structure, Folding, and StabilityCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2010
- The Genetics Concept Assessment: A New Concept Inventory for Gauging Student Understanding of GeneticsCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2008
- Recognizing Student Misconceptions through Ed's Tools and the Biology Concept InventoryPLoS Biology, 2008
- Constructivism and Educational PracticeAustralian Journal of Education, 1996
- Misconceptions & Alternative Conceptions in Science Textbooks: The Role of Teachers as FiltersThe American Biology Teacher, 1996
- Diagnosing secondary students' misconceptions of photosynthesis and respiration in plants using a two-tier multiple choice instrumentJournal of Biological Education, 1987