The Anthropological Difference: What Can Philosophers Do To Identify the Differences Between Human and Non-human Animals?
- 12 April 2012
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement
- Vol. 70, 105-131
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s1358246112000069
Abstract
This paper considers the question of whether there is a human-animal or ‘anthropological difference’. It starts with a historical introduction to the project of philosophical anthropology (sct. 1). Section 2 explains the philosophical quest for an anthropological difference. Sections 3–4 are methodological and explain how philosophical anthropology should be pursued in my view, namely as impure conceptual analysis. The following two sections discuss two fundamental objections to the very idea of such a difference, biological continuity (sct. 5) and Darwinist anti-essentialism (sct. 6). Section 7 discusses various possible responses to this second objection – potentiality, normality and typicality. It ends by abandoning the idea of an essence possessed by all and only individual human beings. Instead, anthropological differences are to be sought in the realm of capacities underlying specifically human societies (forms of communication and action). The final section argues that if there is such a thing as the anthropological difference, it is connected to language. But it favours a more modest line according to which there are several anthropological differences which jointly underlie the gap separating us from our animal cousins.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Can Animals Act For Reasons?Inquiry, 2009
- Philosophische AnthropologiePublished by Springer Science and Business Media LLC ,2009
- Occam’s Razor in science: a case study from biogeographyBiology & Philosophy, 2006
- Evolution of the brain and intelligenceTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2005
- What Makes Human Cognition Unique? From Individual to Shared to Collective IntentionalityMind & Language, 2003
- Animal MindsPublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,2002
- Critique of Pure ReasonPublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,1998
- A Wittgenstein DictionaryPublished by Wiley ,1996
- Exploring Primate Social Cognition: Some Critical Remarks1)Behaviour, 1990
- Punctuated equilibria: the tempo and mode of evolution reconsideredPaleobiology, 1977