Evaluating natural areas using multiple criteria: Theory and practice
- 1 August 1987
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Environmental Management
- Vol. 11 (4), 447-460
- https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01867653
Abstract
Evaluating natural areas involves making measurements for a series of criteria and deciding which areas are most significant based on these measurements. We review the basic theory of measurement and its application to assessing criteria in 20 different conservation evaluation studies. Different types of models exist to assess the overall significance of natural areas based on multiple criteria. A brief description is presented of these “multicriteria evaluation models” and the underlying theory. The assumptions of these models are outlined as are the types of information that are appropriate to each. We then examine how a final overall ranking is derived in the 20 studies. None explicitly stated the model used and few noted the assumptions involved. Based on theory and current practice, a number of principles are presented to guide the development of evaluation methods. We conclude that evaluation methods should not be allowed to cloud important issues or conceal value judgements. Furthermore, the assumptions of any evaluation method should be clearly stated and rationalized in terms of the data and areas being compared.This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Some Quantitative Methods of Assessing the Conservation Value of Ecologically Similar SitesJournal of Applied Ecology, 1985
- Conservation of Polar Bear Pass, Bathurst Island, and the Emerging Comprehensive Conservation Policy for Northern CanadaEnvironmental Conservation, 1985
- Ecological approach to resource survey and planning for environmentally significant Areas: The ABC methodEnvironmental Management, 1984
- Decision making: With applications for environmental managementEnvironmental Management, 1982
- Towards Comprehensive Conservation of Environmentally Significant Areas in the Northwest Territories of CanadaEnvironmental Conservation, 1982
- The IBP Survey of Conservation Sites: An Experimental Study.Journal of Ecology, 1981
- A method for assessing the ornithological interest of sites for conservationBiological Conservation, 1980
- Errata to “A Survey of Multiattribute Utility Theory and Applications”Management Science, 1978
- What is an Economic Index ? An Attempt of an AnswerPublished by Springer Science and Business Media LLC ,1978
- Investigation, evaluation, and priority ranking of natural areasBiological Conservation, 1975