A comparison of alternative kanban control mechanisms. II. Experimental results

Abstract

This paper continues our study of the design of inventory control policies for serial systems. Using simulation, we compare alternate control policies where a target of mean throughput has to be met under three different objectives - minimize the maximum inventory, minimize the average inventory and minimize the variance of the output - for balanced lines and lines with one bottleneck, The main objectives of this paper are: (1) to study several objectives not amenable to sample path analysis and (2) to show some sets of conditions and objectives under which Constant-Work-in Progress (CONWIP) is preferred over the traditional kanban mechanism, and vice-versa.