Accuracy and Reliability of Automated Gray Matter Segmentation Pathways on Real and Simulated Structural Magnetic Resonance Images of the Human Brain
Open Access
- 18 September 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 7 (9), e45081
- https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0045081
Abstract
Automated gray matter segmentation of magnetic resonance imaging data is essential for morphometric analyses of the brain, particularly when large sample sizes are investigated. However, although detection of small structural brain differences may fundamentally depend on the method used, both accuracy and reliability of different automated segmentation algorithms have rarely been compared. Here, performance of the segmentation algorithms provided by SPM8, VBM8, FSL and FreeSurfer was quantified on simulated and real magnetic resonance imaging data. First, accuracy was assessed by comparing segmentations of twenty simulated and 18 real T1 images with corresponding ground truth images. Second, reliability was determined in ten T1 images from the same subject and in ten T1 images of different subjects scanned twice. Third, the impact of preprocessing steps on segmentation accuracy was investigated. VBM8 showed a very high accuracy and a very high reliability. FSL achieved the highest accuracy but demonstrated poor reliability and FreeSurfer showed the lowest accuracy, but high reliability. An universally valid recommendation on how to implement morphometric analyses is not warranted due to the vast number of scanning and analysis parameters. However, our analysis suggests that researchers can optimize their individual processing procedures with respect to final segmentation quality and exemplifies adequate performance criteria.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Emotion recognition and experience in Huntington disease: a voxel-based morphometry studyJournal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience, 2011
- Evidence of diffuse damage in frontal and occipital cortex in the brain of patients with post-traumatic stress disorderNeurological Sciences, 2011
- Positive Effects of Language Treatment for the Logopenic Variant of Primary Progressive AphasiaJournal of Molecular Neuroscience, 2011
- Basal Forebrain Involvement in Low-Functioning Autistic Children: A Voxel-Based Morphometry StudyAmerican Journal Of Neuroradiology, 2011
- Mapping reliability in multicenter MRI: Voxel‐based morphometry and cortical thicknessHuman Brain Mapping, 2010
- Topographical Disorientation in Mild Cognitive Impairment: A Voxel-Based Morphometry StudyJournal of Clinical Neurology, 2010
- Functional but not structural changes associated with learning: An exploration of longitudinal Voxel-Based Morphometry (VBM)NeuroImage, 2009
- The impact of skull-stripping and radio-frequency bias correction on grey-matter segmentation for voxel-based morphometryNeuroImage, 2008
- A fast diffeomorphic image registration algorithmNeuroImage, 2007
- Measures of the Amount of Ecologic Association Between SpeciesEcology, 1945