Dostoevsky and Education through Punishment
- 20 June 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Review of Politics
- Vol. 80 (3), 463-486
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0034670518000207
Abstract
In an important 1984 paper, “The Moral Education Theory of Punishment,” Jean Hampton argues that the practice of inflicting painful criminal punishments is justified only if punishment is morally educative. Hampton's suggestion forms the point of departure for this article on Dostoevsky'sCrime and Punishment. I show that Dostoevsky agrees with Hampton that punishment should aim at moral reform; however, Dostoevsky presents no evidence that self-punishment or legal punishment reliably cultivates respect for law, legal authority, oneself, or others as moral agents. Instead, Dostoevsky's post-Siberian writings are highly critical of Russian criminal justice, and emphasize that moral education comes through dialogue, reflection, and criticism. This highly individualized treatment may be experienced as painful, but it does not have to result from, and it may even be impeded by, legal “hard treatment.”Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Rethinking Punishment in the Era of Mass IncarcerationPublished by Taylor & Francis Ltd ,2017
- Dostoevsky v. The Judicial Reforms of 1864: How and Why One of Nineteenth-Century Russia’s Greatest Writers Criticized the Nation’s Most Successful ReformRussian Law Journal, 2015
- Punishment and SufferingThe American Philosophical Association Centennial Series, 2013
- PunishmentPublished by Taylor & Francis Ltd ,2012
- Preface: Dostoevsky: A Writer in His TimePublished by Walter de Gruyter GmbH ,2010
- DostoevskyPublished by Walter de Gruyter GmbH ,2010
- Restorative justice in prisonsContemporary Justice Review, 2009
- Learning from the Limitations of Deterrence ResearchCrime and Justice, 2008
- Mens ReaPublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,2006
- The Hermeneutics of the SubjectPublished by Springer Science and Business Media LLC ,2005