Modern statelessness and the British imperial perspective. A comment on Mira Siegelberg’s Statelessness: A Modern History
- 19 January 2021
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in History of European Ideas
- Vol. 47 (5), 801-808
- https://doi.org/10.1080/01916599.2020.1861834
Abstract
If the link between territories and people get severed, what is (or should be) the role of international law and the international community? In Statelessness. A Modern History, Mira Siegelberg (University of Cambridge) guides the reader through the answers jurists, philosophers, and diplomats have given to that question since the nineteenth century. Siegelberg is less interested in the question why the postwar arrangement failed so miserably in its plea to reduce statelessness than in the architecture of international law and its role in the debate about legal identity. Her choice of subject is one few historians have touched upon and her work is a corrective to the dominant understanding that international law did not concern itself with the plight of the stateless until after the Second World War. However, her overemphasis on legal scholars from the former Central European empires obscures the role of British ideas about and contributions to international law, legal identity, and the role of the state that might prove crucial to understand modern statelessness that emerged at the dissolution of colonial empires. Nevertheless, Siegelberg's brilliant and important book will likely form the start of a conversation on a topic that merits further historical investigation.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Unmaking of Citizenship of Rohingyas in MyanmarPublished by Springer Science and Business Media LLC ,2020
- Irony of Citizenship: Descent, National Belonging, and Constitutions in the Postcolonial African StateLaw & Society Review, 2019
- How in Myanmar “National Races” Came to Surpass Citizenship and Exclude RohingyaJournal of Contemporary Asia, 2017
- The politics of dispersal: Turning Ugandan colonial subjects into postcolonial refugees (1967–76)Migration Studies, 2017
- Statelessness, identity cards and citizenship as status in the case of the Nubians of KenyaCitizenship Studies, 2014
- THE KENYAN ASIANS, BRITISH POLITICS, AND THE COMMONWEALTH IMMIGRANTS ACT, 1968The Historical Journal, 1999
- Preparing and presenting a human rights briefCommonwealth Law Bulletin, 1991
- Aspecten van sociologisch onderzoekSouth African Journal of Sociology, 1973