From Sacrifice to the Slaughterhouse
- 6 May 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Brill in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
- Vol. 26 (2), 111-158
- https://doi.org/10.1163/15700682-12341269
Abstract
This essay uses a focus on meat and animals to illumine ancient and modern discourses about sacrifice and “civilization.” It suggests that attention to recent research on meat-production and the “sociology of the slaughterhouse” might open new perspectives on the range of ways in which the sanctified ritual slaughter of animals has been understood by its proponents, critics, and theorists—both ancient and modern. It begins by historicizing the rise of modern scholarly interest in animal sacrifice, with reference to dramatic shifts in the production and consumption of meat in modern European societies. Then, it looks to the Vedas and the Torah/Pentateuch to reflect upon the place of meat and animals in two of the best documented of ancient sacrificial systems. Lastly, it considers some trajectories in their Nachleben with an eye to the value and limits of dominant narratives about the cessation, interiorization, or spiritualization of sacrifice. This essay uses a focus on meat and animals to illumine ancient and modern discourses about sacrifice and “civilization.” It suggests that attention to recent research on meat-production and the “sociology of the slaughterhouse” might open new perspectives on the range of ways in which the sanctified ritual slaughter of animals has been understood by its proponents, critics, and theorists—both ancient and modern. It begins by historicizing the rise of modern scholarly interest in animal sacrifice, with reference to dramatic shifts in the production and consumption of meat in modern European societies. Then, it looks to the Vedas and the Torah/Pentateuch to reflect upon the place of meat and animals in two of the best documented of ancient sacrificial systems. Lastly, it considers some trajectories in their Nachleben with an eye to the value and limits of dominant narratives about the cessation, interiorization, or spiritualization of sacrifice.Keywords
This publication has 101 references indexed in Scilit:
- The complex Nature of Religious Sacrifice in the Mahabharata, in the Bagavadgita, and in general. A Cross-cultural Comparison between Indian and Western Theories of Religious SacrificeNeue Zeitschrift für Systematische Theologie und Religionsphilosophie, 2008
- CIVILIZATION: THE CAREER OF A CONTROVERSIAL CONCEPTHistory and Theory, 2006
- Humanity and InhumanityOrganization & Environment, 2004
- Meiji Modernization, Scientific Agriculture, and the Destruction of Japan's Hokkaido WolfEnvironmental History, 2004
- A Neglected Feature of Sacrifice in the Hebrew Bible: Remarks on the Burning Rite on the AltarHarvard Theological Review, 2004
- Taming Nature, Taming Workers: Constructing the Separation Between Meat Consumption and Meat Production in the U.S.Sociologia Ruralis, 2002
- Down to Earth: Nature, Agency, and Power in HistoryThe American Historical Review, 2002
- Getting down to the meat: The symbolic construction of meat consumptionCommunication Studies, 1998
- SACRIFICE AND PAGAN BELIEF IN FIFTH- AND SIXTH-CENTURY BYZANTIUMPast & Present, 1990
- The Symbolism of Blood and SacrificeJournal of Biblical Literature, 1969