Prediction of Graft Survival of Living-Donor Kidney Transplantation: Nomograms or Artificial Neural Networks?
- 27 November 2008
- journal article
- Published by Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health) in Transplantation
- Vol. 86 (10), 1401-1406
- https://doi.org/10.1097/tp.0b013e31818b221f
Abstract
An artificial neural networks (ANNs) model was developed to predict 5-year graft survival of living-donor kidney transplants. Predictions from the validated ANNs were compared with Cox regression-based nomogram. Out of 1900 patients with living-donor kidney transplant; 1581 patients were used for training of the ANNs (training group), the remainder 319 patients were used for its validation (testing group). Many variables were correlated with the graft survival by univariate analysis. Significant ones were used for ANNs construction of a predictive model. The same variables were subjected to a multivariate statistics using Cox regression model; their result was the basis of a nomogram construction. The ANNs predictive model and the nomogram were used to predict the graft survival of the testing group. The predicted probability(s) was compared with the actual survival estimates. The ANNs sensitivity was 88.43% (95% confidence interval [CI] 86.4-90.3), specificity was 73.26% (95% CI 70-76.3), and predictive accuracy was 88% (95% CI 87-90) in the testing group, whereas nomogram sensitivity was 61.84% (95% CI 50-72.8) with 74.9% (95% CI 69-80.2) specificity and predictive accuracy was 72% (95% CI 67-77). The positive predictive value of graft survival was 82.1% and 43.5% for the ANNs and Cox regression-based nomogram, respectively, and the negative predictive value was 82% and 86.3% for the ANNs and Cox regression-based nomogram, respectively. Predictions by both models fitted well with the observed findings. These results suggest that ANNs was more accurate and sensitive than Cox regression-based nomogram in predicting 5-year graft survival.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Predicting Kidney Transplant Survival Using Tree-Based ModelingASAIO Journal, 2007
- Utility of a Mathematical Nomogram to Predict Delayed Graft Function: A Single-Center ExperienceTransplantation, 2006
- When and how to use informatics tools in caring for urologic patientsNature Reviews Endocrinology, 2005
- Validation of a nomogram for predicting disease‐specific survival after an R0 resection for gastric carcinomaCancer, 2005
- Validation of the postoperative nomogram for 12‐year sarcoma‐specific mortalityCancer, 2004
- Predicting creatinine clearance by a simple formula following live-donor kidney transplantationTransplant International, 2004
- Non‐linear survival analysis using neural networksStatistics in Medicine, 2004
- Comparison of Cox Regression With Other Methods for Determining Prediction Models and NomogramsJournal of Urology, 2003
- Prediction of 3‐yr cadaveric graft survival based on pre‐transplant variables in a large national datasetClinical Transplantation, 2003
- An algorithm for cadaver kidney allocation based on a multivariate analysis of factors impacting on cadaver kidney graft survival and functionTransplant International, 2000