The Death of an Elephant: Conservation Discourses Versus Practices in Africa
- 20 October 2010
- journal article
- editorial material
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Forum for Development Studies
- Vol. 37 (3), 385-408
- https://doi.org/10.1080/08039410.2010.516406
Abstract
Environmental conservation in Africa is predominantly presented by key actors in terms of a win–win discourse involving community participation and benefits. By using two case studies from Tanzania and South Africa, we demonstrate how the conservation practices observed do not fit the win–win discourse, but are more in line with the ‘fortress conservation’ that previously dominated both discourse and practice. The Tanzanian case shows how conservation practices may be associated with recentralization instead of devolution and economic marginalization instead of poverty alleviation. The South African case demonstrates that even in a clear‐cut case of fortress conservation, the rhetoric of the win–win discourse is applied. Furthermore, we argue that international conservationists as well as African authorities have their interests served by a presentation of conservation as advantageous to local people. Conservation NGOs are primarily concerned with extending large‐scale protection of landscapes even if poor people have to bear the costs. African governments also try to attract tourist investments. In addition, in the Tanzanian case, the wildlife sector provides an opportunity for personal rent‐seeking for government officials. Both conservation NGOs and African governments apply the win–win discourse to justify their interventions. One may argue, however, that practising the fortress approach might be counter‐productive to wildlife conservation, for instance by producing more opposition to conservation in the form of local killings of elephants.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Anti‐Politics as Political Strategy: Neoliberalism and Transfrontier Conservation in Southern AfricaDevelopment and Change, 2010
- Authority over Forests: Empowerment and Subordination in Senegal's Democratic DecentralizationDevelopment and Change, 2009
- Understanding traditionalist opposition to modernization: narrative production in a norwegian mountain conflictGeografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography, 2008
- Namaqualand—A brief overview of the physical and floristic environmentJournal of Arid Environments, 2007
- Environmental perceptions and practices of livestock keepers on the Namaqualand Commons challenge conventional rangeland managementJournal of Arid Environments, 2007
- Land Reform, Range Ecology, and Carrying Capacities in Namaqualand, South AfricaAnnals of the American Association of Geographers, 2006
- Contested land tenure reform in South Africa: experiences from NamaqualandDevelopment Southern Africa, 2005
- Partitioned Nature, Privileged Knowledge: Community‐based Conservation in TanzaniaDevelopment and Change, 2003
- The demography of an African elephant (Loxodonta africana) population in Amboseli, KenyaJournal of Zoology, 2001
- Foucault, Foucauldians and SociologyBritish Journal of Sociology, 1998