Mapping whose reality? Geographic information systems (GIS) and “wild science”
- 1 October 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Understanding of Science
- Vol. 15 (4), 411-434
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0963662506061885
Abstract
In taking the landscape-scale view increasingly demanded of natural resource management, scientific assessments make considerable use of geographic information systems (GIS) maps to convey the research findings they develop. Public interaction with scientists over natural resource management issues is therefore frequently mediated by such maps, which can directly influence how the landscape is viewed, and how science findings are communicated and understood. Analysis of the Coastal Landscape Analysis and Modeling Study (CLAMS) project in western Oregon reveals that GIS maps play a significant role in how we frame and address natural resource management issues. They can support the role of privileged knowledge as held by the map makers, typically scientists, and may reinforce it by the de facto “map tyranny” that gives primacy to scientific worldviews. But they can also enable broader kinds of inquiry through multiple frames of reference, enhancing story-making opportunities for stakeholders. Which of these trajectories is followed is affected by resource availability and new perceptions of responsibility, each of which reflects social power structures. The CLAMS case study suggests that map user/non-scientists appear less likely to be victims of “map tyranny” the more familiar they are with the technology. Accordingly, they become more likely to push for usable results from it, and more confident about engaging their own knowledge with that of the map maker/scientists.This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fighting over the Forests: Environmental Conflict and Decision‐making Capacity in Forest Planning ProcessesAustralian Geographical Studies, 2003
- Data-gathering strategies for social-behavioural research about participatory geographical information system useInternational Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2002
- The Distribution and Resolution of the Ambiguities of Technology, or Why Bobby Can't SpraySocial Studies of Science, 2001
- Knowledge management: problems, promises, realities, and challengesIEEE Intelligent Systems, 2001
- A Framework and Software Tool to Support Collaborative Landscape Analysis: Fitting Square Pegs into Square HolesTransactions in GIS, 2001
- Conforming (to) the opposition: the social construction of geographical information systems in social movementsInternational Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2000
- Adapting GIS Technology to the Needs of Local PlanningEnvironment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 2000
- Teaching Geographical Information Handling Skills for Lower-income CountriesTransactions in GIS, 1999
- Information Equity, Public Understanding of Science, and the Biotechnology DebateJournal of Communication, 1995
- A Cultural Interpretation of Inuit Map AccuracyGeographical Review, 1990