A meta-analysis of sugarbeet yield responses to nitrogen fertilizer measured in England since 1980
- 23 February 2009
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Agricultural Science
- Vol. 147 (3), 287-301
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0021859609008478
Abstract
SUMMARY: The data from 161 experiments testing the response of sugarbeet yield to nitrogen fertilizer were assembled in a database. Three commonly used N response models (Mitscherlich, linear plus exponential and bilinear) were fitted to each set of fertilizer application rates and the models were then assessed on how well they fitted all the data. The bilinear model was judged the most appropriate model for fitting to beet root yield adjusted to a standard sugar concentration. The optimum N application was determined for each experiment. Attempts were then made to correlate these optima with factors associated with the site and the season (winter rainfall, soil texture, amount of soil mineral N at sowing, sowing date, summer rainfall and harvest date). Beet grown in peat soil never responded significantly to any applied N fertilizer and neither did crops treated recently with organic manure supplying large amounts (>150 kg N/ha) of available N. Variation in N optima between other sites could not be explained by factors that could be used to predict the amount of fertilizer to apply. In the absence of any method to make reliable predictions of variations in fertilizer need, the most economical uniform amount was calculated. At present fertilizer prices and beet values, this amount is between 100 and 110 kg N/ha. It is possible that the N fertilizer need of beet crops does not vary predictably because this variation is an experimental error. The crop needs a reasonably standard application of fertilizer because much N has to be taken up early in the crop's development, rapidly and predominantly from the topsoil that, at this stage, contains most of the small fibrous root system.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Nitrogen fertilizer and the efficiency of the sugar beet crop in late summerEuropean Journal of Agronomy, 2008
- AgronomyPublished by Wiley ,2006
- Plant Structure and Crop PhysiologyPublished by Wiley ,2006
- Estimation of the nitrogen requirement of winter wheat in the UK: a multiple regression approachJournal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 2002
- An analysis of the agronomic, economic and environmental effects of applying N fertilizer to sugarbeet (Beta vulgaris)The Journal of Agricultural Science, 1996
- The dynamics of nitrogen uptake and its remobilization during the growth of sugar beetThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1986
- Fibrous root growth and water use of sugar beetThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1985
- Nutrient relations of winter wheat: 2. Movement of nutrients to the root and their uptakeThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1979
- Water relations of winter wheat: 1. Growth of the root systemThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1978
- Nitrogen requirement of sugar beet grown on mineral soilsThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1970