What’s the Harm? The Coverage of Ethics and Harm Avoidance in Research Methods Textbooks
- 2 June 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Teaching Sociology
- Vol. 46 (1), 12-24
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0092055x17711230
Abstract
Methods textbooks play a role in socializing a new generation of researchers about ethical research. How do undergraduate social research methods textbooks portray harm, its prevalence, and ways to mitigate harm to participants? We conducted a content analysis of ethics chapters in the 18 highest-selling undergraduate textbooks used in sociology research methods courses in the United States and Canada in 2013. We found that experiments are portrayed as the research design most likely to harm participants. Textbooks overwhelmingly referred to high-profile, well-known examples of harmful research. Chapters primarily characterize participants as at risk for psychological and physical harm. Textbooks engage in detailed discussions of how to avoid harm; informed consent figures prominently as an essential way to mitigate risk of harm. We conclude that textbooks promote a procedural rather than nuanced approach to ethics and that content in ethics chapters is out of step with scholarly research in research ethics.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Navigating ethical moments when researching substance misuse with parents and their childrenQualitative Research, 2013
- Textbook mediation of teaching: an example from tertiary mathematics instructorsEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2011
- Research Impacting Social Contexts: The Moral Import of Community-Based Participatory ResearchAmerican Journal of Bioethics, 2011
- Researching Personal Information on the Public WebSocial Science Computer Review, 2010
- The Ethics of ObservingTeaching Sociology, 2008
- Coverage and Representations of Sexuality in Introductory Sociology TextbooksTeaching Sociology, 2007
- Teaching Against the Text: The Case of Qualitative MethodsTeaching Sociology, 2006
- Categorical Usages and Complex Realities: Race, Ethnicity, and Religion in the United StatesSocial Forces, 2003
- Using a Mock Institutional Review Board to Teach Ethics in Sociological ResearchTeaching Sociology, 1999
- On the ethics of intervention in human psychological research: With special reference to the Stanford prison experimentCognition, 1973