Declining Performativity
- 15 March 2012
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Theory, Culture & Society
- Vol. 29 (2), 107-123
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0263276412438413
Abstract
This article explores what might happen to the concept of performativity within arguments that are understood as ‘topological’. It argues that we might ‘decline’ performativity, which is to say, elaborate the concerns that are expressed in the concept, but inclining it more boldly towards the complexities of a world whose elements are always in process of constitution, of reiterative enfolding. Taking a cue from Isabelle Stengers’ recent work in which she posits the notion of ecologies of practice, on the one hand, and Whitehead’s concept of concern, on the other, the paper argues that emergent entities have differential requirements – not least according to the disciplines to which they appeal – and subtend different modes of implied obligation. An adherence to these requirements needs to be accompanied by persuasive presentation that obliges a community to affirm any entity. On many levels of abstraction, ecologies need to show concern for an entity to facilitate its emergence and to sustain its mode of being. In an expanded vision, then, human and non-human entities at all levels enter into multifarious relational modes of becoming, but these become of sustained consequence only through persuasion of communities, sometimes organized into disciplines. The survival of entities requires forms of differentiation, division and of value. The paper relates these arguments to forms of sociological enquiry that give glimpses of how sociology might respond. It ends with a hesitation around the radical anti-anthropomorphism of the stance developed, and argues that this does not entirely eclipse the importance of political hope.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- PERFORMATIVITIES: BUTLER, CALLON AND THE MOMENT OF THEORYJournal of Cultural Economy, 2010
- Vibrant MatterPublished by Duke University Press ,2010
- Without CriteriaPublished by MIT Press ,2009
- From Performativity to Ecology: On Judith Butler and Matters of SurvivalSubjectivity, 2008
- Meeting the Universe HalfwayPublished by JSTOR ,2007
- Pharmaceutical MattersTheory, Culture & Society, 2005
- Politiques de la naturePublished by CAIRN ,2004
- Why Has Critique Run out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of ConcernCritical Inquiry, 2004
- The Psychic Life of PowerPublished by Walter de Gruyter GmbH ,1997
- Order out of ChaosPhysics Today, 1985