Youth culture, physical education and the question of relevance: after 20 years, a reply to Tinning and Fitzclarence
- 1 January 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Sport, Education and Society
- Vol. 18 (1), 97-114
- https://doi.org/10.1080/13573322.2012.690341
Abstract
This article is an attempt to think through the idea that physical education should draw from youth culture in order to be more ‘relevant’ to students. We begin by revisiting Tinning and Fitzclarence's 1992 article ‘Postmodern youth culture and the crisis in Australian secondary school physical education’ in which they essentially argued that young people were bored by physical education because it had failed to keep pace with the pleasures they derive from consumer culture. With this as a starting point, we try to both critique and extend Tinning and Fizclarence's ideas by drawing on two broad areas of scholarship; cultural studies of youth and participatory action research. Our purpose here is twofold. First, we want to help clarify what might be meant by the terms ‘youth culture’ and ‘relevance’. Flowing on from this, we suggest some directions for practice and research. These suggestions are not ‘solutions’ and we are at pains to argue that the ‘relevance problem’ may in fact be an unwitting shorthand for a range of related but distinct challenges. Because of this, as well as our own differing perspectives, we propose contradictory paths forward, including both more and less interest in student subjectivity and more and less allowance for student autonomy.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- “The Boys Won't Let Us Play:“ Fifth-Grade Mestizas Challenge Physical Activity Discourse at SchoolResearch Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 2010
- Young people's views on the nature and purposes of physical education: a sociological analysisSport, Education and Society, 2006
- Physical education, lifelong participation and ‘the couch potato society’1Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 2004
- Canaries in the Coal Mine: Responding to Disengaged Students Using Theme-Based CurriculaQuest, 2000
- Physical Culture, Physical Education and Relational AnalysisSport, Education and Society, 1999
- The Case for a Body‐Focus in Education and Physical EducationSport, Education and Society, 1999
- Student Voice as Agency: Resistance and Accommodation in Inner‐City SchoolsAnthropology & Education Quarterly, 1998
- The Construction of Complementarity in Physical EducationGender and Education, 1996
- Changing Secondary School Physical EducationQuest, 1992
- Postmodern Youth Culture and the Crisis in Australian Secondary School Physical EducationQuest, 1992