Redefining Disease? The Nosologic Implications of Molecular Genetic Knowledge
- 1 December 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Project MUSE in Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
- Vol. 49 (1), 99-114
- https://doi.org/10.1353/pbm.2006.0012
Abstract
How will developments in genetic knowledge affect the classification of disease? Leaders in genetics have suggested that knowledge of the role of genes in disease can determine nosology. Diseases might be defined by genotype, thus avoiding the limitations of more empirical approaches to categorization. Other commentators caution against disease definitions that are detached from the look and feel of disease, and argue for an interplay between genotypic and phenotypic information. Still others attribute nosologic change to social processes. We draw on an analysis of the scientific literature, our conversations with genetics clinicians, and reviews of patient organization Web sites to offer a revised interpretation of the nosologic implications of molecular genetic knowledge. We review the recent histories of three diseases—hemophilia, Rett syndrome, and cystic fibrosis—to argue that nosologic change cannot be explained by either biologic theories of disease etiology or sociologic theories of social tendencies. Although new genetic information challenges disease classifications and is highly influential in their redesign, genetic information can be used in diverse ways to reconstruct disease categories and is not the only influence in these revisions. Ironically, genetic information is likely to play a central role in producing a new, but still empirical, classification scheme.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Influence of MECP2 gene mutation and X-chromosome inactivation on the Rett syndrome phenotype.Journal of Child Neurology, 2004
- Odd MECP2-mutated Rett variant—long-term follow-up profile to age 25European Journal of Paediatric Neurology, 2003
- Nonclassic cystic fibrosis and CFTR-related diseasesCurrent Opinion in Pulmonary Medicine, 2003
- A vision for the future of genomics researchNature, 2003
- An update on clinically applicable diagnostic criteria in Rett syndrome: Comments to Rett Syndrome Clinical Criteria Consensus Panel Satellite to European Paediatric Neurology Society Meeting Baden Baden, Germany, 11 September 2001European Journal of Paediatric Neurology, 2002
- What Is Cystic Fibrosis?The New England Journal of Medicine, 2002
- Infantile hypotonia as a presentation of rett syndromeAmerican Journal of Medical Genetics, 2002
- Laboratory standards and guidelines for population-based cystic fibrosis carrier screeningGenetics in Medicine, 2001
- Time to think again: Cystic fibrosis is not an ?all or none? diseasePediatric Pulmonology, 2000
- Male Rett VariantNeuropediatrics, 1995