"May I Buy a Pack of Marlboros, Please?" A Systematic Review of Evidence to Improve the Validity and Impact of Youth Undercover Buy Inspections
Open Access
- 5 April 2016
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 11 (4), e0153152
- https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0153152
Abstract
Most smokers become addicted to tobacco products before they are legally able to purchase these products. We systematically reviewed the literature on protocols to assess underage purchase and their ecological validity. We conducted a systematic search in May 2015 in PubMed and PsycINFO. We independently screened records for inclusion. We conducted a narrative review and examined implications of two types of legal authority for protocols that govern underage buy enforcement in the United States: criminal (state-level laws prohibiting sales to youth) and administrative (federal regulations prohibiting sales to youth). Ten studies experimentally assessed underage buy protocols and 44 studies assessed the association between youth characteristics and tobacco sales. Protocols that mimicked real-world youth behaviors were consistently associated with substantially greater likelihood of a sale to a youth. Many of the tested protocols appear to be designed for compliance with criminal law rather than administrative enforcement in ways that limited ecological validity. This may be due to concerns about entrapment. For administrative enforcement in particular, entrapment may be less of an issue than commonly thought. Commonly used underage buy protocols poorly represent the reality of youths' access to tobacco from retailers. Compliance check programs should allow youth to present themselves naturally and attempt to match the community's demographic makeup.This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Minority youth access to tobacco: A neighborhood analysis of underage tobacco salesHealth & Place, 2009
- Is it time to abandon youth access programmes? * Authors' repliesTobacco Control, 2002
- Sociocultural Variables in Youth Access to Tobacco: Replication 5 Years LaterPreventive Medicine, 2000
- The Impact of Untruthful Age Reporting During Tobacco Compliance ChecksJournal of Public Health Management and Practice, 2000
- A Comparison of the Advertising and Accessibility of Cigars, Cigarettes, Chewing Tobacco, and Loose TobaccoPreventive Medicine, 1999
- Impediments to the enforcement of youth access lawsTobacco Control, 1999
- Minors' Access to Single Cigarettes in CaliforniaPreventive Medicine, 1998
- Tobacco Control joins Index Medicus and MedlineTobacco Control, 1996
- A baseline assessment of cigarette sales to minors in San Diego, CaliforniaJournal of Community Health, 1993