When Theories Don't Add Up: Disentangling he Manipulatives Debate
- 29 October 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Theory Into Practice
- Vol. 46 (4), 309-316
- https://doi.org/10.1080/00405840701593899
Abstract
The use of manipulatives in the classroom has been advocated for decades. However, the theoretical and empirical support for this practice is mixed. Some researchers suggest that manipulatives facilitate learning by (a) providing an additional channel for conveying information, (b) activating real-world knowledge, and/or (c) improving memory through physical action. However, there are at least two reasons to question the efficacy of manipulative use. First, manipulatives might lead students to focus on having fun at the expense of deep learning. Second, manipulatives might make learning more difficult because they require dual representation. Although these two criticisms are disparate in terms of their underlying rationale, both converge on the idea that teachers should reduce their use of manipulatives that are highly familiar and/or perceptually interesting. More generally, the manipulatives debate highlights the need for teachers and researchers to work together to evaluate the costs and benefits of various classroom practices.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Activity and Imagined Activity Can Enhance Young Children's Reading Comprehension.Journal of Educational Psychology, 2004
- The transfer of abstract principles governing complex adaptive systemsCognitive Psychology, 2003
- Equal Sharing and Shared Meaning: The Development of Fraction Concepts in a First-Grade ClassroomCognition and Instruction, 1999
- Children's strategy use and interpretations of mathematical representationsThe Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 1998
- Using a Base-Ten Blocks Learning/Teaching Approach for First- and Second-Grade Place-Value and Multidigit Addition and SubtractionJournal for Research in Mathematics Education, 1990
- Activation of Real-World Knowledge in the Solution of Word ProblemsCognition and Instruction, 1989
- Why are some problems hard? Evidence from Tower of HanoiCognitive Psychology, 1985
- Mathematics in the streets and in schoolsBritish Journal of Developmental Psychology, 1985
- The Manipulative Materials Strategy: The Latest Pied Piper?Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 1978
- Models and mathematicsThe Arithmetic Teacher, 1972