A Novel Tumor Grading Scheme for Chromophobe Renal Cell Carcinoma
- 1 September 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health) in The American Journal of Surgical Pathology
- Vol. 34 (9), 1233-1240
- https://doi.org/10.1097/pas.0b013e3181e96f2a
Abstract
Chromophobe renal cell carcinoma (RCC) is a histologic subtype of RCC that portends a favorable prognosis. It is controversial whether the Fuhrman nuclear grade of chromophobe RCC has prognostic utility. Irregular nuclei, prominent nucleoli, and nuclear pleomorphism are inherently present in chromophobe RCC. Hence, the Fuhrman nuclear grade is higher even though the majority of these tumors have a favorable outcome. In this study, the prognostic utility of a novel 3-tiered tumor grading system in which the innate nuclear atypia of chromophobe RCC was discounted, herein referred to as chromophobe tumor grade from a series of 124 chromophobe RCC, was compared with Fuhrman nuclear grade. Chromophobe tumor grade is based on the assessment of geographic nuclear crowding and anaplasia. The Fuhrman nuclear grade distribution between the tumors was grade 1 (1%), grade 2 (19%), grade 3 (74%), and grade 4 (6%), whereas the chromophobe tumor grade distribution was grade 1 (74%), grade 2 (16%), and grade 3 (10%). Neither Fuhrman nuclear grade nor chromophobe tumor grade was significantly associated with patient's age or sex and chromophobe RCC cell types, but both showed a significant association with tumor size. Both Fuhrman nuclear grade and chromophobe tumor grade showed statistically significant positive associations with broad alveolar growth, necrosis, vascular invasion, and with pathologic stage; however, all these associations tended to be dictated by tumors with sarcomatoid change. When tumors with sarcomatoid change were excluded, a strong positive association persisted between chromophobe tumor grade and pathologic stage. In contrast, there was no such association between Fuhrman nuclear grade and stage in nonsarcomatoid chromophobe RCCs. Characterizing aggressive chromophobe RCC with aggressive behavior with the time from surgery to first occurrence of metastasis, local recurrence, or death owing to disease, we found that both Fuhrman nuclear grade and chromophobe tumor grade were highly associated with adverse outcome. However, as with the pathologic stage, only a significant association between chromophobe tumor grade and outcome was retained among nonsarcomatoid chromophobe RCCs. Multivariable Cox regression analysis also tended to support chromophobe tumor grade rather than Fuhrman nuclear grade as an independent predictor of adverse outcome, controlling for other univariably significant risk factors [estimated relative hazard=3.68 (P=0.026) vs. 1.86 (P=0.42)]. In conclusion, the novel chromophobe tumor grading system proposed herewith provides superior prognostic value to that of the Fuhrman nuclear grade in chromophobe RCC and will potentially help stratify patients of chromophobe RCC who are at a greater risk of disease progression.This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Chromophobe Renal Cell Carcinoma: Histomorphologic Characteristics and Evaluation of Conventional Pathologic Prognostic Parameters in 145 CasesThe American Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2008
- Fuhrman Grading is not Appropriate for Chromophobe Renal Cell CarcinomaThe American Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2007
- Effect of papillary and chromophobe cell type on disease-free survival after nephrectomy for renal cell carcinomaAnnals of Surgical Oncology, 2004
- Incidental Detection beyond Pathological Factors as Prognostic Predictor of Renal Cell CarcinomaEuropean Urology, 2003
- Comparisons of Outcome and Prognostic Features Among Histologic Subtypes of Renal Cell CarcinomaThe American Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2003
- Prognostic Impact of Histologic Subtyping of Adult Renal Epithelial NeoplasmsThe American Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2002
- Prognostic Value of Renal Cell Carcinoma Nuclear Grading: Multivariate Analysis of 333 CasesUrologia Internationalis, 2001
- Chromophobe Cell Carcinoma of the KidneyThe American Journal of Surgical Pathology, 1995
- Chromophobe Cell Renal Carcinoma: Clinicopathological Features of 50 CasesJournal of Urology, 1995
- Renal cell carcinoma II. Histological indicators of prognosisPathology, 1987