Hippocampal volume assessment in temporal lobe epilepsy: How good is automated segmentation?
Open Access
- 23 November 2009
- Vol. 50 (12), 2586-2592
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1528-1167.2009.02243.x
Abstract
Purpose: Quantitative measurement of hippocampal volume using structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a valuable tool for detection and lateralization of mesial temporal lobe epilepsy with hippocampal sclerosis (mTLE). We compare two automated hippocampal volume methodologies and manual hippocampal volumetry to determine which technique is most sensitive for the detection of hippocampal atrophy in mTLE. Methods: We acquired a three‐dimensional (3D) volumetric sequence in 10 patients with left‐lateralized mTLE and 10 age‐matched controls. Hippocampal volumes were measured manually, and using the software packages Freesurfer and FSL‐FIRST. The sensitivities of the techniques were compared by determining the effect size for average volume reduction in patients with mTLE compared to controls. The volumes and spatial overlap of the automated and manual segmentations were also compared. Results: Significant volume reduction in affected hippocampi in mTLE compared to controls was detected by manual hippocampal volume measurement (p < 0.01, effect size 33.2%), Freesurfer (p < 0.01, effect size 20.8%), and FSL‐FIRST (p < 0.01, effect size 13.6%) after correction for brain volume. Freesurfer correlated reasonably (r = 0.74, p << 0.01) with this manual segmentation and FSL‐FIRST relatively poorly (r = 0.47, p << 0.01). The spatial overlap between manual and automated segmentation was reduced in affected hippocampi, suggesting the accuracy of automated segmentation is reduced in pathologic brains. Discussion: Expert manual hippocampal volumetry is more sensitive than both automated methods for the detection of hippocampal atrophy associated with mTLE. In our study Freesurfer was the most sensitive to hippocampal atrophy in mTLE and could be used if expert manual segmentation is not available.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- A comparison of automated segmentation and manual tracing for quantifying hippocampal and amygdala volumesNeuroImage, 2009
- Automated MRI analysis for identification of hippocampal atrophy in temporal lobe epilepsyEpilepsia, 2009
- Subcortical and cerebellar atrophy in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy revealed by automatic segmentationEpilepsy Research, 2008
- Composite voxel-based analysis of volume and T2 relaxometry in temporal lobe epilepsyNeuroImage, 2008
- Automatic detection and quantification of hippocampal atrophy on MRI in temporal lobe epilepsy: A proof-of-principle studyNeuroImage, 2007
- Quantitative analysis of temporal lobe white matter T2 relaxation time in temporal lobe epilepsyNeuroImage, 2004
- Voxel based morphometry of grey matter abnormalities in patients with medically intractable temporal lobe epilepsy: effects of side of seizure onset and epilepsy durationJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 2002
- Atrophy of mesial structures in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy: Cause or consequence of repeated seizures?Annals of Neurology, 1993
- HIPPOCAMPAL VOLUMETRIC AND MORPHOMETRIC STUDIES IN FRONTAL AND TEMPORAL LOBE EPILEPSYBrain, 1992
- Measures of the Amount of Ecologic Association Between SpeciesEcology, 1945