Organ Procurement Organization Survey of Practices and Beliefs Regarding Prerecovery Percutaneous Liver Biopsy in Donation After Neurologic Determination of Death

Abstract

BACKGROUND Prerecovery liver biopsy (PLB) allows histological evaluation of the organ prior to procurement. The opinions and what factors might influence PLB use within Organ Procurement Organizations (OPOs) are unknown. METHODS A survey instrument was distributed by the Association of OPOs to the clinical directors of all 58 OPOs. Descriptive statistics were calculated. Results were also stratified based on OPO characteristics. RESULTS 84.5% (49/58) OPOs responded to the survey; 81.6% (40/49) currently perform PLB. This did not vary based on land mass, population, livers discarded, transplanted, donor age, or recipient MELD scores. Donor age, obesity, alcohol abuse, hepatitis serology, liver only donor, imaging results and transplant center request were the most common indications for PLB in over 80% of OPOs. The median rate of performance is 5-10% of donors. Most utilize interventional radiologists to perform and the donor hospital pathologist/s to interpret PLB. Most OPOs believe PLBs are safe, reliable, useful, and performed often enough. Most say they did not believe they are easy to obtain. Beliefs were mixed regarding accuracy. The topics likely to influence PLB use were utility and accuracy of PLB, and availability of staff to perform PLB. OPOs that perform PLB more often were more likely to have favorable opinions of safety and pathologist availability, and more influenced by safety, reliability, availability, and a national consensus on the use of PLB. CONCLUSION Considerable variability exists in the use of PLB. Additional information on the utility, accuracy and safety of PLB are needed to optimize its use.