The Social and Psychological Costs of Peer Review
Open Access
- 19 May 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Management Inquiry
- Vol. 25 (1), 11-26
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1056492615586597
Abstract
Research has evolved into a high-stake competition for journal space. This study examines the effects of peer rejections on individual scholars. I propose a transactional framework that organizes experiences with peer rejections into identity-related appraisal and coping phases. I consider two types of response options: peer rejections either as a threat or as a challenge to scholarly identities. I develop research proposition specific to socio-demographic, socio-linguistic, and social-cognitive antecedents of scholarly engagement. I test for main and interaction effects of peer rejections on data collected from 411 International Business scholars. Broadly supportive of my propositions, the findings highlight extensive social and psychological costs of peer-review mechanisms, most notably living with professional failure, resultant cognitive dissonance, and awareness of discriminatory clues. The systematic exploration of bifurcating scholarly work into “valued” and “less valued” contributions invites us to reconsider the way we interact as scholars, create knowledge, and build disciplinary capacities.Keywords
This publication has 95 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mastering One’s DestinyPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2013
- Bias in peer reviewJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2012
- Appraising Stigmatization and Discrimination: Construction and Validation of a Questionnaire Assessing Threat and Challenge Appraisals to Personal and Social IdentityIdentity, 2012
- Conservatism and risk-taking in peer review: Emerging ERC practicesResearch Evaluation, 2012
- To publish or not to publish? On the aggregation and drivers of research performanceScientometrics, 2010
- Editorial JudgmentsSocial Studies of Science, 2009
- The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory.Psychological Bulletin, 1996
- Resiliency and Vulnerability to Adverse Developmental Outcomes Associated With PovertyAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 1991
- Publication prejudices: An experimental study of confirmatory bias in the peer review systemCognitive Therapy and Research, 1977
- Task performance as a function of perceived effort performance and performance-reward contingenciesOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1972