Comparison of Interobserver Agreement of Four Classification Systems for Lateral Clavicle Fractures between Two Groups of Surgeons: A Multicenter Study
Open Access
- 30 January 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Orthopaedic Surgery
- Vol. 15 (8), 2138-2143
- https://doi.org/10.1111/os.13659
Abstract
Objective Distal clavicle fracture classification directly affects the treatment decisions. It is unclear whether the classification systems implemented differ depending on surgeons' backgrounds. This study aimed to compare the interobserver agreement of four classification systems used for lateral clavicle fractures by shoulder specialists and general trauma surgeons.Methods Radiographs of 20 lateral clavicle fractures representing a full spectrum of adult fracture patterns were analyzed by eight experienced shoulder specialists and eight general trauma surgeons from 10 different hospitals. All cases were graded according to the Orthopedic Trauma Association (OTA), Neer, Jager/Breitner, and Gongji classification systems. To measure observer agreement, Fleiss' kappa coefficient (kappa) was applied and assessed.Results When only X-ray films were presented, both groups achieved fair agreement. However, when the 3D-CT scan images were provided, improved interobserver agreement was found in the specialist group when the OTA, Jager/Breitner, and Gongji classification systems were used. In the generalist groups, improved agreement was found when using the Gongji classification system. In terms of interobserver reliability, the OTA, Neer, and Jager/Breitner classification systems showed better agreement among shoulder specialists, while a slightly lower level of agreement was found using the Gongji classification system. For the OTA classification system, interobserver agreement had a mean kappa value of 0.418, ranging from 0.446 (specialist group) to 0.402 (generalist group). For the Neer classification system, interobserver agreement had a mean kappa value of 0.368, ranging from 0.402 (specialist group) to 0.390 (generalist group). For the Jager/Breitner classification system, the inter-observer agreement had a mean kappa value of 0.380, ranging from 0.413 (specialist group) to 0.404 (generalist group). For the Gongji classification system, interobserver agreement had a mean kappa value of 0.455, ranging from 0.480 (specialist group) to 0.485 (generalist group).Conclusion Generally speaking, 3D-CT scans provide a richer experience that can lead to better results in most classification systems of lateral clavicle fractures, highlighting the value of digitization and specialization in diagnosis and treatment. Competitive interobserver agreement was exhibited in the generalist group using the Gongji classification system, suggesting that the Gongji classification is suitable for general trauma surgeons who are not highly experienced in the shoulder field.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Interrater and Intrarater Agreement of a Modified Neer Classification System and Associated Treatment Choice for Lateral Clavicle FracturesThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2015
- Fracture of distal end clavicle: A reviewJournal of Clinical Orthopaedics and Trauma, 2014
- Die laterale KlavikulafrakturOperative Orthopädie und Traumatologie, 2014
- Specialization in MedicineJAMA, 2012
- OTA Fracture ClassificationJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 2009
- Classification Systems in OrthopaedicsJournal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, 2002
- [Therapy related classification of lateral clavicular fracture].1984
- The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical DataBiometrics, 1977
- The Equivalence of Weighted Kappa and the Intraclass Correlation Coefficient as Measures of ReliabilityEducational and Psychological Measurement, 1973
- A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal ScalesEducational and Psychological Measurement, 1960