The Allometry of Coarse Root Biomass: Log-Transformed Linear Regression or Nonlinear Regression?
Open Access
- 8 October 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 8 (10), e77007
- https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0077007
Abstract
Precise estimation of root biomass is important for understanding carbon stocks and dynamics in forests. Traditionally, biomass estimates are based on allometric scaling relationships between stem diameter and coarse root biomass calculated using linear regression (LR) on log-transformed data. Recently, it has been suggested that nonlinear regression (NLR) is a preferable fitting method for scaling relationships. But while this claim has been contested on both theoretical and empirical grounds, and statistical methods have been developed to aid in choosing between the two methods in particular cases, few studies have examined the ramifications of erroneously applying NLR. Here, we use direct measurements of 159 trees belonging to three locally dominant species in east China to compare the LR and NLR models of diameter-root biomass allometry. We then contrast model predictions by estimating stand coarse root biomass based on census data from the nearby 24-ha Gutianshan forest plot and by testing the ability of the models to predict known root biomass values measured on multiple tropical species at the Pasoh Forest Reserve in Malaysia. Based on likelihood estimates for model error distributions, as well as the accuracy of extrapolative predictions, we find that LR on log-transformed data is superior to NLR for fitting diameter-root biomass scaling models. More importantly, inappropriately using NLR leads to grossly inaccurate stand biomass estimates, especially for stands dominated by smaller trees.This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Coarse root biomass allometric equations for Abies balsamea, Picea mariana, Pinus banksiana, and Populus tremuloides in the boreal forest of Ontario, CanadaBiomass and Bioenergy, 2011
- Influence of Environmental Variability on Root Dynamics in Northern ForestsCritical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 2009
- A phyletic perspective on the allometry of plant biomass‐partitioning patterns and functionally equivalent organ‐categoriesNew Phytologist, 2006
- Quantifying the coarse-root biomass of intensively managed loblolly pine plantationsCanadian Journal of Forest Research, 2006
- Tree allometry and improved estimation of carbon stocks and balance in tropical forestsOecologia, 2005
- Below- and above-ground biomass, production and nitrogen use in Scots pine stands in eastern FinlandForest Ecology and Management, 2002
- The influence of fire on carbon distribution and net primary production of borealLarix gmeliniiforests in north‐eastern ChinaGlobal Change Biology, 2001
- The impact of human disturbance on vegetative carbon storage in forest ecosystems in ChinaForest Ecology and Management, 2001
- MEASURING NET PRIMARY PRODUCTION IN FORESTS: CONCEPTS AND FIELD METHODSEcological Applications, 2001
- Carbon Dynamics of Rocky Mountain Douglas‐Fir: Influence of Water and Nutrient AvailabilityEcological Monographs, 1992