Pre-residency publication and its association with paediatric residency match outcome—a retrospective analysis of a national database
Open Access
- 13 November 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 6 (6), 388-395
- https://doi.org/10.1007/s40037-017-0383-8
Abstract
Introduction Scholarly activity is considered valuable in the resident selection process by candidates and program directors alike, despite existing literature suggesting applicants with scholarly work do not perform better in the match. These studies, however, are limited in that they have only measured whether candidates have successfully matched or not. To try and reconcile the existing disconnect in the value of pre-residency scholarly activity, we sought to deepen the understanding by investigating whether pre-residency publication is associated with a higher rank-order list match achievement. Methods Anonymized data were collected from the Canadian Residency Matching Service for individuals matched to paediatric programs from 2007–2012. The primary analysis was to identify whether documentation of ≥1 pre-residency publication was associated with achieving a first-choice match. Secondary analyses included evaluating for an association between multiple pre-residency publications, academic presentations or a graduate degree and match outcome. Results Of a total of 843 matched individuals, 406 (48.2%) listed ≥1 pre-residency publication and 494 (58.6%) matched to their first-choice program. The possession of ≥1 pre-residency publications was not associated with matching to a candidate’s first-choice program (odds ratio = 0.94 [95% confidence interval = 0.71–1.24], p = 0.66). Similarly, listing ≥2 publications, ≥3 publications, a graduate degree, or an academic presentation was not associated with achieving a first-choice match. Conclusions The results provide increased support for the notion that in aggregate, candidate scholarly activity does not influence match outcome.Keywords
Funding Information
- Children’s Hospital of Eastern Ontario Research Institute Resident Research Grant (RS2013-05)
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Prevalence of Research Publication Misrepresentation Among Urology Residency Applicants and Its Effect on Match SuccessUrology, 2016
- Associations between residency selection strategies and doctor performance: a meta-analysisMedical Education, 2013
- Pre-residency Publication Rate Strongly Predicts Future Academic Radiology PotentialAcademic Radiology, 2012
- Success in the Pediatric Surgery Match: a survey of the 2010 applicant poolJournal of Pediatric Surgery, 2011
- A Meta-Analysis of Studies of Publication Misrepresentation by Applicants to Residency and Fellowship ProgramsAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Can Medical School Performance Predict Residency Performance? Resident Selection and Predictors of Successful Performance in Obstetrics and GynecologyJournal of Graduate Medical Education, 2010
- Factors Associated with Successful Performance in an Orthopaedic Surgery ResidencyThe Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, 2009
- Selection Criteria for Residency: Results of a National Program Directors SurveyAcademic Medicine, 2009
- The Importance of Basic Science and Clinical Research as a Selection Criterion for General Surgery Residency ProgramsJournal of Surgical Education, 2008
- An analysis of orthopaedic residency selection criteria.2003