The new IOC and IAAF policies on female eligibility: old Emperor, new clothes?
- 2 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Informa UK Limited in Sport, Ethics and Philosophy
- Vol. 8 (1), 44-56
- https://doi.org/10.1080/17511321.2014.899613
Abstract
The Caster Semenya debacle touched off by the 2009 Berlin World Athletics Championships resulted finally in IOC and IAAF abandonment of sex testing, which gave way to procedures that make female competition eligibility dependent upon the level of serum testosterone, which must be below the male range or instrumentally countered by androgen resistance. We argue that the new policy is unsustainable because (i) the testosterone-performance connection it posits is uncompelling; (ii) testosterone-induced female advantage is not ipso facto unfair advantage; (iii) the new policy reflects the gender policing impulses endemic to sport as well as the broader cultural impulses to monstrify women and to doctor women who have nothing wrong with them; (iv) female–male performance disparities are not the only reason for sex-segregated sport, but co-exist with respectable cultural and practical reasons, which (v) provide a powerful case for allowing athletes to compete in the sex category congruent with their gender identity.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Out of Bounds? A Critique of the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female AthletesAmerican Journal of Bioethics, 2012
- Testing sex and gender in sports; reinventing, reimagining and reconstructing historiesEndeavour, 2010
- Oral contraceptives decrease saliva testosterone but do not affect the rise in testosterone associated with athletic competitionHormones and Behavior, 2009
- Defining advantage and athletic performance: The case of Oscar PistoriusEuropean Journal of Sport Science, 2009
- Should Oscar Pistorius be Excluded from the 2008 Olympic Games?Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2008
- Transsexuals in Sport–Fairness and Freedom, Regulation and LawSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2008
- Current anti-doping policy: a critical appraisalBMC Medical Ethics, 2007
- Testosterone, cortisol, and women's competitionEvolution and Human Behavior, 2002
- Height outcome in congenital adrenal hyperplasia caused by 21-hydroxylase deficiency: A meta-analysisThe Journal of Pediatrics, 2001
- The Effects of Supraphysiologic Doses of Testosterone on Muscle Size and Strength in Normal MenNew England Journal of Medicine, 1996