Proof of efficacy of different modified sonic sealer inserts used for debridement in furcations - a dummy head trial

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to determine the suitability of different scaling instruments for surgical removal of hard and soft bacterial deposits and for the removal of soft accretions only for maintenance treatment within furcations. 12 upper and 12 lower plastic replicated molars, with through-and-through furcations, were instrumented 3 x with 4 different types of instruments: (1) hand instruments; (2) a conventional sonic scaler insert; (3) a set of 3 modified sonic scaler inserts with budded tips and different angulated shafts; (4) a set of 3 sonic scaler inserts with a plastic-coating and different angulated shafts. The plastic replicas were fixed in a dummy head without any replicated soft tissues. In the furcation area, an easily removable surface coating material was applied to the teeth to represent the "plaque" and a second, more stubborn lacquer layer representing "calculus/cementum". Following instrumentation, the following parameters were recorded to assess efficacy; time required for instrumentation, loss of weight, depth of substance removal at the furcation entrance, % of furcation area instrumented, whereby removal of these 2 layers was judged separately. Only minor differences were observed between hand instruments, conventional and budded sonic scaler inserts as to loss of weight, depth of substance loss and area instrumented. The plastic-coated sonic scaler inserts were just as effective in surface layer removal representing "plaque" as the 3 other instruments, but resulted in less loss of weight and less depth of substance removal. In conclusion, the more aggressive hand instruments, the conventional and budded sonic scaler insert, are preferably used for the surgical phase to increased ease of entry into the furcation dome. An effective debridement of the furcation roof seems only possible with an odontoplastic, for which a furcation is fitted to the instrument by means of an intensive instrumentation, thus leading to weight loss and pronounced substance removal. The plastic-coated sonic scaler inserts seems to be a reasonable choice for maintenance treatment within furcation, since this treatment phase is usually restricted to removal of soft bacterial deposits.