Disciplinary Socialization: Learning to Evaluate the Quality of Scholarly Literature
- 26 May 2007
- book chapter
- Published by Emerald in Advances in Library Administration and Organization
Abstract
There is an increasing interest in incorporating information literacy (IL) instruction into undergraduate curricula in higher education (HE) as a stand alone specialism, "a soft applied discipline" on its own. However, diverse and conflicting views exist about whether information use and evaluation can be taught as discrete activities in isolation from disciplinary content and context, and who, faculty or librarians, should be teaching information literacy. This article seeks to shed additional light on these issues by empirically exploring how literature evaluation and use is taught by faculty in four fields: physics, medicine, social politics and social work, and literature. Using Becher's (1989) characterizations of academic fields along the dimensions hard-soft and pure-applied, convergent and divergent, rural and urban, we explore the relationships between the nature of knowledge production within the fields studied and their practices of teaching literature use and evaluation. The findings indicate that IL is best conceived as something that can not be meaningfully approached or taught as separate from disciplinary contents and contexts. Information skills must be taught in ways that are wholly integrated with the ways literature is searched, used, and evaluated within disciplines.This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- The social and discursive construction of computing skillsJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2004
- Reasons for the use and non‐use of electronic journals and databasesJournal of Documentation, 2003
- Information Literacy in Higher Education: A review and case studyStudies in Higher Education, 2003
- Disciplinary differences and undergraduates' information‐seeking behaviorJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2002
- Not just a matter of time: Field differences and the shaping of electronic media in supporting scientific communicationJournal of the American Society for Information Science, 2000
- Document structure and digital libraries: how researchers mobilize information in journal articlesInformation Processing & Management, 1999
- Information Literacy in Science and Engineering Undergraduate Education: Faculty Attitudes and Pedagogical PracticesCollege & Research Libraries, 1999
- Texts at Work: Some Thoughts on "Jus† for You" Service in the Context of Domain ExpertiseJournal of Education for Library and Information Science, 1998
- The characteristics of subject matter in different academic areas.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1973