Cognitive processes in engineering design: a longitudinal study
- 1 November 1994
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Ergonomics
- Vol. 37 (11), 1753-1786
- https://doi.org/10.1080/00140139408964950
Abstract
In this paper we report an empirical study of the cognitive processes of semi-expert electronics engineers pursuing real-world design projects. Extensive diary and interview data were analysed so as to reveal the organization of on-going design activity and the goals that were motivating behaviour. Our analyses indicated that subjects were implementing a highly systematic design strategy which deviated only a small amount (12%) from a top-down, depth-first procedure. Some of this deviation could be accounted for by social demands impinging on the individual designer, and whilst there was also evidence of ‘opportunistic’ deviation from a structured design approach, this did not appear to be a significant feature of our subjects' behaviour. We present a model of the design process as a set of production rules which describe an abstract ‘design schema’ for electronic engineering. This design schema embodies processes which control and co-ordinate problem-understanding and problem-structuring activity as well as the essentially top-down, depth-first pursuit of design solutions. The schema also allows for flexibility in the design process, permitting subjects to cope with contingencies arising through social influences and performance breakdowns. A further aspect of the design schema is that it encapsulates a ‘satisficing’ procedure which reflects a principle that dominated our engineers' solution-search and evaluation activity—they characteristically focused exclusively on initial, satisfactory (but usually sub-optimal) solution concepts rather than comparing alternatives with the aim of optimizing choices. We conclude our discussion by recommending facilities that we feel computer-based design aids should offer users if they are to be genuinely useful adjuncts to design activity.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- The structure of Design Problem SpacesCognitive Science, 1992
- More or less following a plan during design: opportunistic deviations in specificationInternational Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 1990
- A model of the mechanical design process based on empirical dataArtificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing, 1988
- Mapping cognitive demands in complex problem-solving worldsInternational Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 1987
- A model of software designInternational Journal of Intelligent Systems, 1986
- Pragmatic versus syntactic approaches to training deductive reasoningCognitive Psychology, 1986
- Strategies and biases in human decision-making and their implications for expert systemsBehaviour & Information Technology, 1986
- Pragmatic reasoning schemasCognitive Psychology, 1985
- Schema induction and analogical transferCognitive Psychology, 1983
- The structure of ill structured problemsArtificial Intelligence, 1974