Informed Consent as a Litigation Strategy in the Field of Aesthetic Surgery: An Analysis Based on Court Precedents
Open Access
- 1 September 2016
- journal article
- Published by Georg Thieme Verlag KG in Archives of Plastic Surgery
- Vol. 43 (05), 402-410
- https://doi.org/10.5999/aps.2016.43.5.402
Abstract
Background In an increasing number of lawsuits doctors lose, despite providing preoperative patient education, because of failure to prove informed consent. We analyzed judicial precedents associated with insufficient informed consent to identify judicial factors and trends related to aesthetic surgery medical litigation. Methods We collected data from civil trials between 1995 and 2015 that were related to aesthetic surgery and resulted in findings of insufficient informed consent. Based on these data, we analyzed the lawsuits, including the distribution of surgeries, dissatisfactions, litigation expenses, and relationship to informed consent. Results Cases were found involving the following types of surgery: facial rejuvenation (38 cases), facial contouring surgery (27 cases), mammoplasty (16 cases), blepharoplasty (29 cases), rhinoplasty (21 cases), body-contouring surgery (15 cases), and breast reconstruction (2 cases). Common reasons for postoperative dissatisfaction were deformities (22%), scars (17%), asymmetry (14%), and infections (6%). Most of the malpractice lawsuits occurred in Seoul (population 10 million people; 54% of total plastic surgeons) and in primary-level local clinics (113 cases, 82.5%). In cases in which only invalid informed consent was recognized, the average amount of consolation money was KRW 9,107,143 (USD 8438). In cases in which both violation of non-malfeasance and invalid informed consent were recognized, the average amount of consolation money was KRW 12,741,857 (USD 11,806), corresponding to 38.6% of the amount of the judgment. Conclusions Surgeons should pay special attention to obtaining informed consent, because it is a double-edged sword; it has clinical purposes for doctors and patients but may also be a litigation strategy for lawyers.Funding Information
- Ewha Womans University
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ethical Issues in Chinese Aesthetic SurgeryAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2014
- Ethical Principles of Informed Consent: Exploring Nurses’ Dual Role of Care Provider and ResearcherJournal of continuing education in nursing, 2014
- Mammaplasties and Medicolegal Issues: 50 Cases of Litigation in Aesthetic Surgery of the BreastAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2011
- An Approach to Selected Legal Issues: Confidentiality, Mandatory Reporting, Abuse and Neglect, Informed Consent, Capacity Decisions, Boundary Issues, and Malpractice ClaimsMedical Clinics of North America, 2010
- Complaints, grievances, and claims against physicians: Does tort reform make a difference?Journal of Healthcare Risk Management, 2010
- An Introduction to Medical Malpractice in the United StatesClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 2009
- The therapeutic misconception and our models of competency and informed consentBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2006
- [The origin of informed consent].2005