Quantifying the Trade-off between Parameter and Model Structure Uncertainty in Life Cycle Impact Assessment
- 23 July 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 47 (16), 9274-9280
- https://doi.org/10.1021/es305107s
Abstract
To enhance the use of quantitative uncertainty assessments in life cycle impact assessment practice, we suggest to quantify the trade-off between parameter uncertainty, i.e. any uncertainty associated with data and methods used to quantify the model parameters, and model structure uncertainty, i.e. the uncertainty about the relations and mechanisms being studied. In this paper we show the trade-off between the two types of uncertainty in a case of maize production with a focus on freshwater ecotoxicity due to pesticide application in The Netherlands. Parameter uncertainty in pesticide emissions, chemical-specific data, effect and damage data, and fractions of metabolite formation of degradation products was statistically quantified via probabilistic simulation, i.e. Monte Carlo simulation. Model structure uncertainties regarding the concentration–response model to be included, the selection of the damage model, and the inclusion of pesticide transformation products were assessed via discrete choice analysis. We conclude that to arrive at a minimum level of overall uncertainty the linear concentration–response model is preferable, while the transformation products may be excluded. Selecting the damage model has a relatively low influence on the overall uncertainty. Our study shows that quantifying the trade-off between different types of uncertainty can help to identify optimal model complexity from an uncertainty point of view.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do interspecies correlation estimations increase the reliability of toxicity estimates for wildlife?Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 2012
- Identification and classification of uncertainties in the application of environmental modelsEnvironmental Modelling & Software, 2010
- New challenges in integrated water quality modellingHydrological Processes, 2010
- Transformation Products in the Life Cycle Impact Assessment of ChemicalsEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2010
- Future research challenges for incorporation of uncertainty in environmental and ecological decision-makingEcological Modelling, 2008
- Characterizing, Propagating, and Analyzing Uncertainty in Life‐Cycle Assessment: A Survey of Quantitative ApproachesJournal of Industrial Ecology, 2007
- Combining Quantitative and Qualitative Measures of Uncertainty in Model‐Based Environmental Assessment: The NUSAP SystemRisk Analysis, 2005
- Quantifying and reducing uncertainty in life cycle assessment using the Bayesian Monte Carlo methodScience of The Total Environment, 2005
- Toward less misleading comparisons of uncertain risks: the example of aflatoxin and alar.Environmental Health Perspectives, 1995
- Uncertainty Analysis in Multiplicative ModelsRisk Analysis, 1994