Security Risk Management by Qualitative Vulnerability Analysis

Abstract

Security risk assessment in the requirements phase is challenging because risk factors, such as probability and damage of attacks, are not always numerically measurable or available in the early phases of development. This makes the selection of proper security solutions problematic because mitigating impacts and side-effects of solutions are not often quantifiable. In the early development phases, analysts need to assess risks in the absence of numerical measures or deal with a mixture of quantitative and qualitative data. We propose a risk analysis process which intertwines security requirements engineering with a vulnerability-centric and qualitative risk analysis method. The proposed method is qualitative and vulnerability-centric, in the sense that by identifying and analyzing common vulnerabilities the probability and damage of risks are evaluated qualitatively. We also propose an algorithmic decision analysis method that considers risk factors and alternative security solutions, and helps analysts select the most cost-effective solution. The decision analysis method enables making a decision when some of the available data is qualitative.