Evaluation of automated brain MR image segmentation and volumetry methods
- 6 June 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Human Brain Mapping
- Vol. 30 (4), 1310-1327
- https://doi.org/10.1002/hbm.20599
Abstract
We compare three widely used brain volumetry methods available in the software packages FSL, SPM5, and FreeSurfer and evaluate their performance using simulated and real MR brain data sets. We analyze the accuracy of gray and white matter volume measurements and their robustness against changes of image quality using the BrainWeb MRI database. These images are based on “gold‐standard” reference brain templates. This allows us to assess between‐ (same data set, different method) and also within‐segmenter (same method, variation of image quality) comparability, for both of which we find pronounced variations in segmentation results for gray and white matter volumes. The calculated volumes deviate up to >10% from the reference values for gray and white matter depending on method and image quality. Sensitivity is best for SPM5, volumetric accuracy for gray and white matter was similar in SPM5 and FSL and better than in FreeSurfer. FSL showed the highest stability for white (20% for the simulated data and 24% on average for the real data sets, whereas within‐method performance analysis uncovered volume differences of up to >15%. Since the discrepancies between results reach the same order of magnitude as volume changes observed in disease, these effects limit the usability of the segmentation methods for following volume changes in individual patients over time and should be taken into account during the planning and analysis of brain volume studies. Hum Brain Mapp, 2009.Keywords
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- A pilot study of facial, cranial and brain MRI morphometry in men with schizophrenia: Part 2Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging, 2006
- Measurements of the Amygdala and Hippocampus in Pathologically Confirmed Alzheimer Disease and Frontotemporal Lobar DegenerationArchives of Neurology, 2006
- A new improved version of the realistic digital brain phantomNeuroImage, 2006
- Differential brain growth in the infant born preterm: Current knowledge and future developments from brain imagingSeminars in Fetal and Neonatal Medicine, 2005
- Unified segmentationNeuroImage, 2005
- Normative estimates of cross-sectional and longitudinal brain volume decline in aging and ADNeurology, 2005
- Age does not increase rate of forgetting over weeks—Neuroanatomical volumes and visual memory across the adult life-spanJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 2005
- Automatic segmentation of subcortical brain structures in MR images using information fusionIEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging, 2001
- Review of MR image segmentation techniques using pattern recognitionMedical Physics, 1993
- Multispectral analysis of magnetic resonance images.Radiology, 1985