School Effectiveness Research: criticisms and recommendations
- 1 December 1998
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Informa UK Limited in Oxford Review of Education
- Vol. 24 (4), 421-438
- https://doi.org/10.1080/0305498980240401
Abstract
Much research on school effectiveness has been characterised by largely overstated claims and poor modelling. School effectiveness research (SER) has tended to define ‘effectiveness’ in terms of a restricted and often inappropriate range of outcomes, to overlook the issue of curriculum alignment, to be limited by the absence of longitudinal data, and it has often been characterised by unsupported assumptions about the homogeneity of school ‘effects’. SER needs to provide justification for the interpretation of ‘effectiveness’ defined as the unexplained part of performance in a statistical model, and a much clearer conception of why certain relationships exist is required. SER has yet to demonstrate the extent to which differences among schools in their ‘effectiveness’ are really caused by identifiable factors within the school and, more importantly, factors within the school's control; evaluations of school improvement interventions are generally unconvincing in this respect. Repeated findings of ‘correlates’ associated with ‘effectiveness’ (particularly when the strengths of the associations are not reported) are no substitute for a well grounded understanding of the specific mechanisms by which schools have their effects. A number of recommendations for future research are made.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- School Effectiveness Research and its Critics: alternative visions of schoolingCambridge Journal of Education, 1996
- Multilevel Modelling in School Effectiveness ResearchSchool Effectiveness and School Improvement, 1996
- Using Examination Results as Indicators of School and College PerformanceJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, 1996
- Academic Motivation and School Performance: Toward a Structural ModelContemporary Educational Psychology, 1995
- Estimating Differences in the Examination Performances of Secondary Schools in Six LEAs: a multi‐level approach to school effectivenessOxford Review of Education, 1990
- Statistics and Causal InferenceJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1986
- Statistical Modelling Issues in School Effectiveness StudiesJournal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A (General), 1986
- A‐level Results in Comprehensive Schools: the COMBSE project, Year 1Oxford Review of Education, 1985
- Transforming the Frog into a Prince: Effective Schools Research, Policy, and Practice at the District LevelHarvard Educational Review, 1984
- The Coleman Report: Using Inappropriately Designed Achievement TestsAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1975