The ‘standardization of catastrophe’: Nuclear disarmament, the Humanitarian Initiative and the politics of the unthinkable
- 13 September 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of International Relations
- Vol. 23 (3), 681-702
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1354066116666332
Abstract
This article reviews the recent Humanitarian Initiative in the nuclear disarmament movement and the associated non-proliferation and disarmament literature. It argues that rather than this initiative being a transformative moment in nuclear politics, as claimed by supporters, it instead fits into a long history of nuclear politics as the politics of ‘rethinking the unthinkable’ and, as such, is located not only within the long-established institutions of international society, as realist critics claim, but also within the long-established and limiting forms of speech of international society. The article questions the limitations of the dominant framing of nuclear weapons as ‘unthinkable’, and claims that focusing on the seemingly trivial matter of the prevalence of cliché in this discourse actually reveals a deeper problem of the limits of this approach. In doing so, the article shows how the problem of standardised, repetitive ways of speaking, reliance on ‘nukespeak’, and dominant tropes of nuclear speech identified in much of the literature is not that of the somehow innate ‘unthinkability’ of nuclear weapons, but that this ‘unthinkability’ and the associated ‘unspeakability’ of the nuclear are rhetorical frames that limit the possibility for political change.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bourdieu and the bomb: Power, language and the doxic battle over the value of nuclear weaponsEuropean Journal of International Relations, 2013
- The Resurgent Idea of World GovernmentEthics & International Affairs, 2008
- the gothic scene of international relations: ghosts, monsters, terror and the sublime after september 11Review of International Studies, 2005
- Nuclear technoaesthetics: Sensory politics from trinity to the virtual bomb in Los AlamosAmerican Ethnologist, 2004
- The strath report: britain confronts the H‐Bomb, 1954–1955History and Technology, 2003
- Nuclear Weapons as Obstacles to International SecurityInternational Relations, 2002
- Tacit Knowledge, Weapons Design, and the Uninvention of Nuclear WeaponsAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1995
- The rhetoric of nukespeakCommunication Monographs, 1989
- Writing the UnthinkableCritical Inquiry, 1986
- The Cliche in the Reading ProcessSubStance, 1982