The class-inclusion task: Question form and distributive comparisons
- 1 July 1979
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Journal of Psycholinguistic Research
- Vol. 8 (4), 301-331
- https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01067136
Abstract
The class-inclusion task is regarded by Piaget as a measure of the child's mastery of the structure of hierarchical classification. Class-inclusion was improved by changing the wording of the question to conform to standard English usage. A theoretical argument is offered that the child's difficulties with this task derive from confusion of collective comparisons, in which properties of classes are compared, and distributive comparisons, in which properties of elements are compared. A grammatical constraint on expression of distributive comparisons—an element of a class cannot be compared to an element of an included subclass—is hypothesized to be overgeneralized to expressions referring to collective comparisons such as the class-inclusion task. This hypothesis accounts for the improvement in class-inclusion performance with changes in wording of the question and for the finding that young children's responses to class-inclusion questions and to ungrammatical requests for comparison of an element of a class and an element of an included subclass are similar: the children respond readily but understand wrongly that the comparison involves coordinate classes.This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Classes and collections: Internal organization and resulting holistic propertiesCognitive Psychology, 1976
- Counting strategies and semantic analysis as applied to class inclusionCognitive Psychology, 1976
- Class-Inclusion Failure: Cognitive Deficit or Misleading Reference?Child Development, 1974
- An Analysis of Verbal Facilitation of Class-Inclusion ReasoningChild Development, 1974
- The Facilitation of Part-Whole Comparisons by Use of the Collective Noun "Family"Child Development, 1973
- The Role of Syntax in Children's Comprehension from Ages Six to TwelveMonographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 1970
- Reasons for Failure on the Class Inclusion ProblemChild Development, 1970
- Responses to Class-Inclusion Questions for Verbally and Pictorially Presented ItemsChild Development, 1968
- Experiences Affecting the Development of Number Conservation in ChildrenChild Development, 1965
- Relations between the understanding of the logic of classes and of cardinal number in children.Canadian Journal of Psychology / Revue canadienne de psychologie, 1962