Kirchheimer’s French Twist
- 26 August 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Party Politics
- Vol. 15 (5), 592-614
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1354068809336398
Abstract
Despite the fact that the catch-all thesis has profoundly affected scholarship on political parties, operationalizing the thesis and applying it to evaluate empirical cases has proved challenging for scholars. The thesis has been criticized for lacking a theoretical framework of analysis and clear causal logic. Therefore, while it is often cited it is rarely tested. In this article I develop a model of the catch-all thesis and then test it in the case of France, one of the original cases specified by Otto Kirchheimer in his observations. The French case exhibits competing tendencies of party convergence and polarization with the persistence of ideology. Findings suggest some confirmation of the catch-all thesis prediction regarding bipolarization, yet not according to the rationale asserted in the thesis. Additionally, presidentialism effects prove an important explanatory factor and the 2007 elections suggest a possible catch-all party in the UMP.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Presidentialism Enthroned: The French Presidential and Parliamentary Elections of April May and June 2007Parliamentary Affairs, 2008
- Experimenting with French Election Rules: Initial ResultsFrench Politics, 2007
- Policy competition in the 2002 French legislative and presidential electionsEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2006
- Coalition Strategies and the National Front Vote in French Legislative ContestsFrench Politics, 2005
- Reply: Framing Change in Political Bloc Development: A Rejoinder to Grunberg and SchweisguthFrench Politics, 2003
- Reply to Andersen and Evans, Values, cleavages and party choice in France, 1988–1995French Politics, 2003
- Party Membership in Twenty European Democracies, 1980-2000Party Politics, 2001
- Cadre, Catch-All or Cartel?Party Politics, 1996
- Party system change: The catch‐all thesis revisitedWest European Politics, 1991
- The Future of the Gaullist Majority: An Analysis of French Electoral PoliticsAmerican Journal of Political Science, 1974