Propofol vs thiopentone as anaesthetic agents for short operative procedures

Abstract

In a randomized open study, 120 healthy female patients were included. For short gynaecological procedures they were anaesthetized with either propofol 2.5 mg X kg-1 (n = 60) or thiopentone 5 mg X kg-1 (n = 60) in combination with nitrous oxide/oxygen (67%/33%). Supplementary doses of propofol (10-20 mg) or thiopentone (25-50 mg) were given when necessary during the procedure. Induction characteristics for propofol and thiopentone 1 min after start of induction were similar. Propofol seemed to have a more depressant effect than thiopentone on the circulatory response to anaesthesia. Recovery times from the end of the operative procedure until the patients opened their eyes on command and were orientated were shorter in the propofol patients compared to the thiopentone patients. In the propofol group, patients recalled discomfort on injection more often than patients anaesthetized with thiopentone. Otherwise, the side-effects were similar in both groups. We conclude that propofol is similar to thiopentone in its anaesthetic qualities during induction and maintenance of short anaesthetic procedures. Propofol was associated with a more rapid emergence from anaesthesia than thiopentone.