THE CHANGING PLACE OF VISUAL REPRESENTATION IN ECONOMICS: PAUL SAMUELSON BETWEEN PRINCIPLE AND STRATEGY, 1941–1955
- 16 February 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of the History of Economic Thought
- Vol. 32 (2), 175-197
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s1053837210000143
Abstract
In this paper, we show that Paul Samuelson (1915–2009), renowned as one of the main advocates of the mathematization of economics, has also contributed to the change of the place of visual representation in the discipline. In his early works (e.g. Foundations of Economic Analysis published in 1947), he rejected diagrammatic analysis as a relevant tool of theorizing but used diagrams extensively, both as a pedagogic tool in his introductory textbook Economics (1948) and as a way of clarifying his theory of public expenditure (1954-5). We show that Samuelson’s reluctance to use diagrams in his early works can be explained by his training at Chicago and Harvard and his rejecting Marshall’s economics, whereas his adoption of visual language in Economics was a product of the peculiar context affecting American mass-education after WWII. A methodological debate which opposed him to Kenneth Boulding in 1948 led him to reconsider the place of visual representation in order to clarify conceptual controversies during subsequent debates on mathematical economics. Therefore, it can be said that the prominent place of visual language in the diffusion of economic ideas was stabilized in the mid-1950s, as mathematical language became the prevailing tool of economic theorizing. From this, we conclude that the idea that algebra simply upstaged geometry in the making of economic analysis must be qualified.Keywords
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Late Victorian visual reasoning and Alfred Marshall's economic scienceThe British Journal for the History of Science, 2005
- Graphical Analysis and the Visually Impaired in Undergraduate Economics CoursesThe Journal of Economic Education, 1996
- The Image of ObjectivityRepresentations, 1992
- Facilitating the Transition from Graphical to Algebraic Models: A Teaching Challenge for Intermediate MicroeconomicsThe Journal of Economic Education, 1992
- What Do We Want in an Economics Textbook?The Journal of Economic Education, 1988
- Foundations of Economic Analysis.The Economic Journal, 1950
- Relaying the FoundationsEconomica, 1949
- The Diagrammatical Representation of Cost Conditions in International TradeEconomica, 1932
- Alfred Marshall, 1842-1924The Economic Journal, 1924
- Theory of International ValuesThe Economic Journal, 1894